the underground music magazine    

issue #24 August, 2004

 


Untitled Document

Dear readers,

Welcome to issue #24 of Maelstrom Zine. We nearly always seem to have a whopper of some sort every time we put out an issue. This time is no exception, as our man Tom Orgad somehow managed to get an interview with guitar god Uli Jon Roth. Roth of course made his name with the Scorpions, and then went on to forge a brilliant career that continues to this day.

Alongside the Roth interview are three other fine discussions. We present to you the continuation of last month’s chat with The Forsaken drummer Nicke Grabowski, an interview with Eight Days Gone (whose record we loved and gave away last month), and a talk with Asunder guitarist John Gossard, whose cult status was forever sealed as the leader of defunct Bay Area black metal legend Weakling. (Look out for our in-depth Weakling interview next issue)

Speaking of Asunder, we’re giving away the California doom/death band’s debut full-length, A Clarion Call in this month’s contest, along with power/prog/opera metal Aina’s Days of Rising Doom. Please see our contest section for details.

We’ve got a couple live review for you, including a report from a rare Orphaned Land performance. That plus 56 albums reviewed with our usual objectivity and honesty that we hope you’ve come to expect.

Please welcome our newest writer to the staff. You might have seen a couple reviews last time by a certain The Antichris. Seems like our man didn’t like the name, so we settled on Christraper. And with a name like that, you can bet he’s an authority on black metal.

In other staff news, Tom Orgad has returned to India to face the demons he summoned with his first bout with Vipassana meditation. During his last trek around the country, Tom was hit by a car, a motorcycle, a bike, a bus, a cow, and an elephant. Hopefully he’ll be the wiser this time.

Elsewhere in India, Abhishek Chatterjee is continuing down the road to becoming a certified black belt in electrical engineering, while the entire staff of Maelstrom is in histerics.

And last but not least, Bastiaan de Vries, who you may know as our noise expert, has launched the beginning of his own sordid career in the genre by having his Noise Cock Extravaganza project’s debut put out by Absalom Recordings (www.absalom-recordings.com), and a following album will be released on Samsa Records. An auspicious debut, indeed!

Thanks as always,

Roberto Martinelli

%%alternate_content%%
%%content%%

 

 

 

interview by: Tom Orgad

The career of maestro guitarist Ulrich (or Uli Jon) Roth has surely shown an intriguing, binding sequence of ripening and evolvement. Starting as the axeman of psychedelic-era Scorpions, gradually growing towards a heavy metal orientation with the band, then forming primary neo-classical, spiritually fueled hard rock outfit Electric Sun, and proceeding into an increasingly classical direction – his magical, singular touch has always been present, consisting a unifying common denominator of his enchanting, unearthly artistic presence.

Now, prior to the release of his latest ambitious musical project, titled Requiem, and just before a US tour he is about to embark on together with fellow guitarist Michael Schenker, we were lucky enough to be granted with an hour of his time, to talk of hs view of art and philosophy, as well as his personal career – past, present and future.

Maelstrom: So, what have you been up to these days?

Uli Jon Roth: I have been working on my computer, preparing some music scores. We will have some orchestra recordings in the beginning of August, and I still have to write a lot of music, scores and parts for that, so I'm working very hard at the moment to do that. At the same time I'm also preparing myself for an American tour. We are producing videos for projection in the background. So I'm extremely busy at the moment.

Maelstrom: What are the recordings for? Requiem?

Uli Jon Roth: Yeah.

Maelstrom: Can you say some more regarding this piece? We have been hearing about it for years.

Uli Jon Roth: I don't want to talk about Requiem yet. I only want to talk about it when it is finished, you know. That's better. There were several times in the past when I thought I would finish it, and then I didn't, and [comments were] already out. So I don't really want to do it anymore. It is a very big piece of music. I wrote four hours altogether. But I'm not going to release four hours, because it is going to be too long, too massive. So, I have edited it to be shorter, and then, first of all, I will release the shorter version. Maybe one day I can do the "director's cut."

Maelstrom: It should be interesting. You mentioned preparing videos for the tour.

Uli Jon Roth: I'm going out with a big screen behind me. On screen we are projecting, first of all, images of the orchestra. We are also
projecting moving images of nature, sky, space, to go with the music. On some of the pieces there is a little story going on on the screen, but mostly it is just to enhance the general atmosphere of the music. But all this needs to be produced. I'm doing that at the moment. A director friend of mine is doing part of the work. Some of that I'm giving to others, some of that I'm doing myself. It is an enjoyable work, I really like doing that. But it is time consuming. It is one of the things that I'm doing on the side at the moment.

Maelstrom: Is this a part of your "Lux Artis" concept? I think it is a fascinating matter. On your website and poetry, you talk of music as a sort of divine spark coming out of the stillness.

Uli Jon Roth: The "Lux Artis Ex Tenebre" is quite wide reaching for me. It is like a model which gives a certain umbrella to all creative thought processes. Basically I think that we live in a time and age in which the true spirit of art have really been weakened, neglected and almost forgotten by large sections, of artists even, given away to shallow commercialism and such like. I'm not saying this because "I'm Uli now and I''ve seen so many changes." I'm saying this because I'm really convinced that this is the case. There were certain centuries before us which were really very truthful in terms of creativity. The force of arts was much stronger, and had more meaning in general for our culture.

But these times are long gone. We live in an era in which art has lost a lot of its impact and value in society. This is quite a deplorable state of affairs, and also a dangerous and sad one, from whatever angle you look at it. Art, and I don't mean just visual art, but all artistic endeavours: poetry, artistic writing, painting, music and sculpture, is very important. It is almost like a mirror for society, and for the best, and the most positive that human kindness has brought forward.

Maelstrom: What do you think of the modern views of the avantgarde school of thought, that claims that art should be a part of life, take place in every aspect of the everyday life, exist outside the museum?

Uli Jon Roth: Really great artists can maybe do that, as they are in an artistic state of mind all day long. I like to keep important artistic statements separate from trivial everyday aspects of life. When I go to the bathroom in order to brush my teeth, I may have an artistic idea, but there is nothing artistic about brushing your teeth, because everybody can do it, and it actually not something that has a value besides keeping your body healthy. It doesn't have a spiritual value and such.

Art does not have to be in the museum. Absolutely not. Art can be everywhere, Art can be on your walkman when you listen to music, which you can do in any environment. But I think art is to have a special place in our lives, and museum is a special place. You go to a museum because it is a place where a lot of artistic energy is condensed.

Maelstrom: So, how do you define the artistic dimension? You just said that brushing your teeth is not artistic.

Uli Jon Roth: How do I define it? What is the difference between brushing your teeth or cleaning your shoes, and creating a masterpiece?

Maelstrom: That is what I'm asking. How do you define a masterpiece?

Uli Jon Roth: Well, how do I define a masterpiece. A good question. It is easy for me to define it. I know it when I see it, or I know it when I hear it. It is difficult to describe to others why something is a masterpiece, particularly when you are just talking about something, not a specific piece of art. I could tell you about a certain painting, why I think the painting is a masterpiece. But let me take you up on that challenge. Lets think about it. We should be able to define it.

First of all, I think there are many different levels of artistic expression. Like, a little child of five or six may be gifted. She may be able to draw a little picture of a rabbit and make it look nice. For this child, it is quite an achievement, and certainly an artistic expression, because she is not producing something utilitarian. A few years later that little girl becomes an apprentice in a well known painter's studio. She learns how to draw properly, perspectives, painting techniques, compositions and so forth. But it will not yet allow her to make masterpieces. Although she may have acquired certain abilities, she will still have to travel quite a long distance to be able to get to the next level – to find something of her own style, and then achieve mastery within this genre.

Usually, masterpieces are only produced by masters of the craft. A master is somebody who has deep knowledge of his craft, and can apply that knowledge, but in my book, who also has something extra. And that is the dimension I am talking about. This something extra, which was once very good craftsmanship, is where art really starts. And the more this artist possesses of that extra quality, this undefinable quality – you can call it "genius," on various levels – the greater, usually, his productions will be.

So, when I speak about art, I don't necessarily mean the production of a five year old child. I mean mature pieces of art by mature artists. Of course, there have always been, and will be, young artists who have created masterpieces, but that is usually the exception. I could talk about it for hours, it is such a wide field which was I trying to explain with a simple story, so you can see my train of thought.

Maelstrom: And the additional element, the thing beyond mastery – the spark of genius – do you consider it objective, or subjective?

Uli Jon Roth: Nothing is objective in our life. We cannot be objective. The way our mind works, we can at best be partially objective. It is relatively easy to explain why we cannot be objective. Art is very subjective, but there is such thing, I believe... a common denominator. You will, for instance, find that most people agree roughly about what is beautiful and what is ugly. It has to do with archetypes and symmetry. A little baby will already be more attracted to a face which have perfect symmetry then to one which is completely asymmetrical. Because we have an inborn sense of beauty.

A good artist will have a very strong affinity with this sense. This is the reason why certain pieces of art, like certain Michelangelo, Beethoven or Mozart masterpieces have such a universal appeal on people all over the world, all over the centuries. There is a lot of common ground in how we view these things. But, a person who is not artistic, and not really in tune with art, may not really have developed that sense to some degree, will not be able to tell the difference between a masterpiece and a non-masterpiece. But it is all very subjective.

Maelstrom: I see in your art two different aspects. This of, say, Vivaldi – the classical art, and this of Jimi Hendrix – the one I identify with Dionysos, the spontaneous outburst of energy, a creative impulse. I realize how you say Vivaldi may produce a masterpiece, which is to be almost universal, although subjective. But what about the other pole, Hendrix? Do you consider his works masterpieces as well?

Uli Jon Roth: Absolutely. For me, many of his songs are complete masterpieces. He produced them through having exactly that spark of genius to a very high degree. He did not have training or a lot of technical knowledge, but he was able to transcend all that, because he had so much of the other. And that is why the final result of what he did is so perfect within himself.

Maelstrom: In your creation, you have gradually moved form the "Hendrix Pole," that of Rock, to the one of classical music. Could you point the reason for this?

Uli Jon Roth: The classical has always been a part of my world, but the framework I was working in in the Scorpions and Electric Sun didn't really allow me to bring it so much into the foreground. Afterwards, once I distanced myself from that framework, I was totally freed to do what I wanted at the time, so the orchestral and classical structured elements became much stronger in my music. But the other element is still there. So, as you say, the spontaneous, that force of chaos, almost – I call it "controlled chaos."

Maelstrom: Actually, I was referring only to the Scorpions. I Believe Electric Sun also featured many classical elements.

Uli Jon Roth: Yes, especially in the third album.

Maelstrom: Not only in the third album. My personal favorite album by Electric Sun is actually Earthquake. There is something very primary about it, very primordial, I think. I'd like to know what you went through during the period of the 70's. You have been in the Scorpions, gradually getting detached from them. Then, you form Electric Sun, and suddenly comes this great outburst, stream of ideas, new influences. According to the lyrics, it seems that you where also influenced by Eastern philosophies. What happened back then?

Uli Jon Roth: I was waking up. I think at the time when I was at the Scorpions, I was still somewhat asleep, spiritually and mentally, and also artistically. Then, I met Monika Dannemann. Through this connection I began to realize a lot more things, and actually started to wake up. More and more my creativity started to flow, in a broader sense. All the stuff you see in Electric Sun is an outpouring of that, a result of that creativity. I was creative before then, but I think that with Electric Sun my creativity and artistry went into a higher octave. Quite a few of the songs of the Earthquake album I had already written way before Tokyo Tapes. The title track, originally called "Instead of a Symphony," was written back in 1977, a year before I left the band. So was "Sundown" and some others. It was impossible for me to utilize that music in the framework of Scorpions. It just wouldn't have worked, wouldn't have made sense.

Maelstrom: Did you enjoy your time with the Scorpions during those days? Could you still identify with the hard rock vibe, or feel frustrated and eager to depart?

Uli Jon Roth: I was with the Scorpions for five years, and have enjoyed the first four. The last year I didn't really enjoy so much anymore. In fact, I remember how much I wanted to leave. And that is eventually what I did.

Maelstrom: And it seems that when you left, they went very extremely for a different direction. The album Lovedrive is very different from the previous releases of the 70's. It is much more commercial, and seems to be more targeted to the US market.

Uli Jon Roth: Maybe, I can't really comment on that. I have only heard the album once, and that was at that time, so I don't really remember.

Maelstrom: During your period of "waking up," besides meeting Monika, what were your sources of inspiration? Other artists, lores, spiritual doctrines?

Uli Jon Roth: there were so many, I would have to go back in my mind to that time. Some inspirations were always there, they were just growing. From the beginning, I pretty much did find my own way. Although, I did read a lot of philosophy, and studied all of the major religions and such. But it didn't take me very long to do that, and from the beginning I had a pretty clear idea about my own perception of things. Although, every once in a while I was confronted with some teaching, and it changed. I thought the ancient Indian Yoga tradition had some amazing wisdoms, also the teaching of Buddha. I had no problem to combine these with the Christian tradition, where I was coming from.

Maelstrom: Did you ever become a devotee?

Uli Jon Roth: No. I am only a devotee of Jesus. But I did also have a very good look at the Kabbalah. That was at the time of the first Electric Sun album. In fact, the song "Burning Wheels Turning" had a lot of these symbols in it. I think there is a lot of truth in the Kabbalah, it goes back to ancient times. Just like with Greek Mythology, and others, you have to translate these things in a metaphysical sense. You can't take them too much at face value. Once you start seeing your way, they can be translated. Once you find the key, they can be very helpful. At the time, I was looking for understanding. I was searching both inside and outside of myself. Sometimes I was searching quite intensely, and sometimes more casually. I don't have a particular method with these things. I find that whenever there is a need for me to explore, I do that, as time allows.

Maelstrom: So, has the search has not ended yet?

Uli Jon Roth: It never ends. Absolutely not. That would be just so boring. I'm comfortably learning, and I'm changing. I'm proud to change. I don't want to stay the same. I want to progress and get better. For me, that is very important.

Maelstrom: So what have been your recent findings?

Uli Jon Roth: At this part in my life, I'm working on so many different things creatively. It is a period of my life when I'm actually producing. I don't have much time for reflection at the moment. When I do reflect, it just ends up in the music. I go through phases of my life, and this phase is of pure creativity, not so much of searching.

Maelstrom: Sounds exciting and satisfying.

Uli Jon Roth: I'm quite pleased. The only thing that I don't like is that time is limited and, unfortunately. Pretty much all the things that I start come as big projects, and they seem to take forever. That can lay down a bit, particularly when you want to achieve a certain level of perfection.

Maelstrom: Now, at the upcoming US tour, you are about to hook up with Michael Schenker. Have you kept in touch since the early 70's?

Uli Jon Roth: Not really. Sometimes we exchange some emails and are on good terms. We are friends. But usually, we are always at our own things.

Maelstrom: How does a classical musician (as you are) feel about performing in front of a heavy metal crowd?

Uli Jon Roth: I can perform in front of any crowd. I don't make these
distinctions, because I always try to break through the preconceptions. And normally, that works. I can play in front of an audience of 80 year olds, and in front of an audience of 10 year olds. In front of a heavy metal audience, or a pop audience. Particularly in the last few years, I have found a way to communicate across these boundaries. It doesn't work with every concert, but it does with most of them.

The atmosphere is very different. Every concert is different. I cannot always choose where I'm going to play. I can choose to a certain degree, like refuse certain shows, but on the tour you just play the shows that are on the agenda, which means that some times you play at a concert hall, and some times you end up playing in some club. There, we have to play slightly differently. The environment is different, and the environment effects the music. Also, I wouldn't play the same repertoire in a club and at a seated concert hall. It is a completely different feeling. When the people are standing up and geared up for rock, you can't play too many ethereal slow movements. It just doesn't work.

Maelstrom: What are you intending to play on this tour?

Uli Jon Roth: It will be a very mixed bag. We will play Metamorphosis, some Electric Sun tracks, some Transcendental Sky Guitar, some Scorpions.

Maelstrom: I have also wanted to ask you about a matter that is not really related to what we have talked about so far, but fans all around the world have interest in: it has been said that, at the time, a demo has been recorded for your early band Dawn Road. Is it obtainable in any way?

Uli Jon Roth: No. not really. We don't want to release it. We don't think it is good enough.

Maelstrom: You don't think it is good enough?

Uli Jon Roth: No.

Maelstrom: Because you know, many fans around the world would greatly appreciate it.

Uli Jon Roth: I know, but you can't have it all. Maybe one day when we are dead.

Maelstrom: You should write it in your will.

Uli Jon Roth: I don't want to say "no" completely, because we have changed our minds before. But at the moment, I cannot see it happening.

 

 

 

interview by: Roberto Martinelli

After six years of toil, Oakland, California-based doom metal outfit Asunder is on the brink of releasing its first full length album, A Clarion Call (which we're giving away in our contest for August, 2004), on Nuclear War Now (LP) and Life is Abuse (CD). The entire record can be heard for free at www.asunder.info. The album is made up of three long, crushing doom tracks whose music sounds sorta like 45s played at 33 speed. And Asunder guitarist John Gossard would take that as the highest compliment. We spoke to Gossard at his home in San Francisco, CA, about the band he’s in and where good riffs come from.

Maelstrom: What have you been into lately?

John Gossard: I’ve been really into some of the Black Legions shit, the stuff from France. There’s always been people who are like, “I don’t want anyone to hear my shit.” They have some really cool music. They’re not necessarily the greatest musicians; they have some cool trips on disharmony and ambience, but while still being melodic... and the only thing you have to go on in terms of psychoanalyzing is hearsay, because there are no interviews. And you think, “did they turn their back on the scene because everyone thought that they were full of shit and couldn’t play?”

I know of bands know that are legendary now; people who just grew out of whatever they were doing [musically]. And 10 years later, someone says, “dude! That’s amazing!” And then a bunch of other people are like, “yeah! It IS amazing!” And all of a sudden, this weird cult item becomes famous, and the people in the band don’t even know it because they’re disassociated from everything.

I go on chat rooms and watch similar things evolve, like people who understand how stuff like *that* happened? They say, “I’m going to release a demo with 33 copies, and every one is going to be signed with the name of the person on it. And then people are going to shit talk my band for being too elitist. And I’m going to shit talk them for not being cool enough to know what I’m doing. And THEN, I’m going to do this other thing that’ll be limited, and then this label is going to offer me a record deal because I’ve created hype.” It’s commercialism in the underground, but instead of making money, it’s status. And it’s just as fucking ridiculous as a Coke commercial.

But then again, I trip out on myself: I like the obscurity. It’s puzzling, it’s mysterious.

Maelstrom: Is something still valid if no one gets it?

John Gossard: There’s a certain degree of validity to, “should I present stuff that people just don’t get?” Because they’re perceiving it wrong (?). If I think that Weakling is kind of about Norwegian black metal and kind of about Neurosis, and kind of about The Swans.... if I go play this shit, or hang out with Fenriz and say, “here, listen to my album! And we’ll talk about it.” No one is going to perceive it the way I do; everyone is going to get it wrong. Even people that get what I like will get it wrong.

Maelstrom: Where do good riffs come from?

John Gossard: I can’t imagine anyone that would write speed metal with riffs like (does speed metal impression) That’s such a dumb riff. But if you listen to the song, it’s bad!!! Speed metal has gotten too technical and artsy-fartsy. I don’t even know where the good riffs come from. I can hear technical riffs that sound good, but most of the time it’s the simplistic ones that are the best. And why is one simplistic one generic and another one brilliant? You can follow bands that wrote great shit, and they can’t answer the question – they wrote two good albums and then became more and more generic. Darkthrone still puts out good albums, but they’re not ground-breaking albums. And they don’t know what was ground-breaking about the albums they put out. And Asunder’s next album is going to be horrible...

Maelstrom: HAHAHAHAH! I spoke to Fenriz once. He was telling me about his love for techno music. He said he DJed. I asked him if he’d ever make techno music. He said, “never.” He said how he used to think metal was really cool and mysterious, but then when he joined metal bands and realized how the music was made, the mystery was gone, and it really wasn’t that cool anymore. He said he didn’t want that to happen with techno. Can you relate to that?

John Gossard: Anyone that has played music with me will probably say I’m hard to work with. I always want to change what we’re working on. I definitely have this quality that once something is playable, it doesn’t have mystery, and it seems... obvious. You listen to your own practice tapes from before you could catch whatever it was you couldn’t catch, and you’re like, “fuck, that’s so nuts sounding!” And once you can catch it, it’s like, “where’s the energy?” The whole thing is that there’s this chaos going on, and when you know how to do it, the chaos is gone. And the better musician you become, the more and more complicated music you have to write in order for it to have that chaos. And the more complicated music you write, the less you write what is the root, guttural, great riff. It wasn’t even my decision to do this, but I feel fortunate to play in bands that have been different genres of stuff, because each time, I don’t know what I’m doing. Like with Asunder, I don’t quite know what the rules are, and I end up doing something not normally what I’d think of. It’s a funny thing: I always hate bands when they change styles, but it’s the same people. So maybe I’m avoiding that by joining different bands.

Maelstrom: So the next Asunder would be your first second album?

John Gossard: Yeah. I’m afraid of it.

Maelstrom: (laugh)

John Gossard: The lineup for Asunder is constantly mutating.

Maelstrom: There was Weakling (which originated in Black Goat), then The Gault, then Asunder. Was the last gasp with The Gault the beginning of your being in Asunder?

John Gossard: I was already in Asunder when I quit The Gault.

Maelstrom: When did you join Asunder?

John Gossard: Three years ago, about?

Maelstrom: How long were they together before that?

John Gossard: Another three years? Maybe they started in ‘99, or something? They had started and I was playing with The Gault, and I was playing with Peter, the drummer that I jam with now. Asunder had broken up and re-formed without one of their guitarists. They asked me to join and I decided to do it as The Gault stuff was great, but it wasn’t as metal as I wanted to play.

For me, this stuff in Asunder is always growing, always changing: I’m always going to be able to figure out a different way to write the guitar lines. It’s always interesting for me to play it.

Maelstrom: I keep thinking of this interview I read with Max Cavalera, that was done around 2000 or so. He said something to the effect of, “I’ll never be able to write another Beneath the Remains.” He would never be able to recapture that time. And I think, without being the absolute biggest Beneath the Remains fan, “god! Instead of spending all the time touring or waiting to write another record, if only Sepultura had held off touring and used that Beneath the Remains creative window to write as many songs as they possibly could. If you hunkered down and wroet as much stuff as you could to cover multiple albums, would you be able to defeat your sophomore album blues and fears? Could you trick yourself?

John Gossard: When you look at Asunder, you have to take into account that it’s been a band in which none of the members have any money. We don’t make any money from it. The most money we’ve ever made from a show is half the practice space rent that we owed that month. It’s frustrating, but you do it. Then, comes an opportunity to record. And in the case of the last Asunder album, Billy Anderson (sound engineer who recorded classic doom bands like Sleep, The Melvins, Catherdral) liked us and told us he’d give us a deal because he wanted to record us. And we were like, “we don’t have any money. You want to help us out, that’s awesome, but we don’t have more material than three songs.” We have a couple new songs we’re working on. They’re about 12-15 minutes long.

Maelstrom: Do you like ‘em?

John Gossard: They’re good. I haven’t grown into them yet. We still have to work out the vocals.

I remember when I was a kid... really early on, when I was way into Metallica and Kill ‘Em All and Ride the Lightning... back in the days when Metallica would still play club shows with Exodus and Slayer and Megadeth... I remember wondering if Metallica was ever bummed to not be able to go and see Metallica play.

Maelstrom: Yeah, we’re going back to the theme of your being the worst judge of your own material. I mean, if you had been in Metal Church, maybe you’d be totally bummed about that, too.

John Gossard: I would definitely be bummed about Metal Church. Metal Church is embarrassing as fuck.

Maelstrom: I like the cello on the Asunder record. I think it really makes the songs.

John Gossard: That’s Alex.

Maelstrom: When I saw you play live, there wasn’t any cello.

John Gossard: Alex has never had the proper means to amplify the acoustic cello. We’ve always had problems with intonation and feedback with it. It was the kind of thing where if we were professional and had some sound engineer that would be paid $50 an hour to figure out the problem. We may decide to incorporate the cello into the new material, but we’re not going to fuck with it until the songs are done.

Maelstrom: How about this bonus track that’s going to be on the record?

John Gossard: It’s a track of ambient bullshit. People who know their shit will probably think that it’s deep. It’s not.

Maelstrom: What’s the ambient music made out of?

John Gossard: It’s made from tracks from the album, but you wouldn’t know.

Maelstrom: When I saw you play a couple years ago, I remember the band being frustrated because it wasn’t playing slow enough.

John Gossard: Fast is so much more definable. You know when you’re reaching your limitations. You can always play slower.

Maelstrom: I don’t know, man. I think that in a way, playing really fast is as hard as playing really slow.

John Gossard: Well, it’s hard to play slow and actually be in the groove.

Maelstrom: I remember when I first started playing. My drum teacher would tell me to play something slower if I was having problems with it. Like, at 80 beats per minute, it feels pretty natural. But when you start going down past 60 BPM, to 50 BPM and 40 BPM, things can get hard.

John Gossard: It’s like playing 45s at 33. It sounds sick.

Maelstrom: (looks around Gossard’s room at his record collection, whose LPs are in bookshelves and CDs all stashed away in plastic milk crates) See, I would think you’d have thousands and thousands of records.

John Gossard: I dunno. I don’t buy records to collect them.

Maelstrom: What’s the Clarion Call artwork going to be like?

John Gossard: It’s going to be a bunch of hippies hanging out around an American flag.

Maelstrom: No, seriously.

John Gossard: It’s some picture of a desert sky in the morning. But you wouldn’t recognize it. They had microbes eat the film, and it looks like civilization has been destroyed by microbes. What more do you want out of a rock band?

Maelstrom: You were talking about learning how to play with this band. What’s been the biggest challenge?

John Gossard: I can’t even calculate the ego trips that go on in a rock band. Think about what goes on in any rock band. “Oh, yeah? Well, *I’m* the guitarist.” “*I’m* the bass player!” “*I’m* the drummer.” And then you add to that: “I’m the guitarist, and I play really slow.” “I’m the drummer, and I also play incredibly slow.” And you’re adding this absolutely retarded dynamic to the band. As an outsider, you might think it’s amazing that we could play that way. If you were actually at practice, you’d be seeing a state where fist fights would almost be breaking out. The only reason they don’t break out is because we have guitars and things to defend ourselves with.

Maelstrom: What’s practice like, really?

John Gossard: I just try to make everyone play really slow. Dino (drums) tries to convince us that we’re gonna form a grindcore band. And then Jeff (guitar) goes back to slow. Brit (bass) wanted to go Neurosis, but we’re not playing with him anymore. None of us could be that artistic.

The best Asunder riff to me sounds like a Slayer riff on quarter speed. It’s really hard to write a riff and then slow it down that much before everyone boycotts it.

Maelstrom: What do you like to do best? Practice, play live or record?

John Gossard: Practice. Practicing has nothing to do with any outsiders’ impression of what you’re doing. There’s no reason to be doing it other than you enjoy it. Once you present what you’re working on to anyone, it’s not your own. Any person out there who thinks they’re obscure, but has played their friend their demo tape, cannot pretend they’re in it for their own judgement. They’ve given it out to perception of others. Once you do that, you become so clinically aware of everything you hate about what you do. It’s a very good learning tool, but it’s also a bad thing in terms of having your own personal place to go to. Even if you never play it for anyone ever again, you know that there’s someone out there that has a judgement on something that doesn’t even need to be judged. But the fact is I’m enough of a drunk to not care.

I used to care. People would super-judge the fact that I was trying to do anything related to black metal. Now I play black metal with Peter (drums). It doesn’t sound anything like Weakling. And people are like, “dude! This doesn’t sound like Weakling...”

Asunder is good because I’m totally into it, but it’s not a thing that I formed. Asunder gets praise and shit-talking, but I don’t back up one or the other because I don’t know.

 

 

 

 

interview by: Roberto Martinelli

This is part two of a three part interview with the Forsaken’s Nicke Grabowski, who was kind enough to give us a couple hours of his time to discuss the finer points of his continued progression as a drummer, Icelandic "manhood" cars, and lots and lots of Bolt Thrower. In fact, that’s where we left off in last month’s interview...

Maelstrom: We were talking about the practice of one guitarist recording all the parts on an album, and contrasting that with how Bolt Thrower (who didn’t do that) sounded.

Nicke Grabowski: When you have really brutal guitars, but don’t play really tight, then you’ll end up with a sound like Bolt Thrower’s, a big mess of brutality. You can’t hear all the exact details. It’s very importatn that you can hear everything we do, but still have a brutal sound. It’s always a matter of taste. Some bands want it to be like [a mess]. I think we did quite a good job on Traces of the Past. You can hear most of the stuff, at least.

Maelstrom: The arrangements seem to be breathing a lot more on Traces of the Past than ever before.

Nicke Grabowski: I think we opened it up and got a wider perspective on our own music. For example, we have more variety of beats, instead of having thrash beats all the time.

Maelstrom: The new record made me think of The Crown’s Possessed 13. Specifically, your Arts of Desolation album has more of the typical Swedish sounding riffs, but this one has less of that, which made me think of The Crown: it doesn’t sound so much like a Swedish record, and that’s not a bad thing!

Nicke Grabowski: I haven’t heard Possessed 13 yet, but I think I know exactly what you mean. It’s something we thought a lot about: we wanted to sound like we do, but we wanted to change those things, like getting rid of the At the Gates stamp that we have. At the Gates’ Slaughter of the Soul is a really good album, but it’s been done 200 times. Actually, I don’t understand the comparison. Ok, we had two or three riffs on the first album that were very At the Gates. But our stuff is death metal mixed with thrash. If you go back, the whole thing is Slayer. The things that At the Gates do, they put Slayer riffs in triplets.

Maelstrom: It’s gotten pretty lost. At the Gates was at the start, but so many bands took it from them, and then so many other bands took it from the second round of bands, etc... But they’re all Swedish. Just recently American bands have been starting to incorporate this sound, which is clearly labeled as Swedish. So, going back to The Crown, you can sort of tell it’s a Swedish band from the way the drummer plays his beats, but the picking and riffing style is very not Swedish. It avoids that homogenous playing style that you could call “At the Gates.” Anyway, you’ve lost a lot of that on the new record, and I think that’s good.

Nicke Grabowski: I want our fans to go out, buy the record, and hear it’s The Forsaken. Bands change their style so much that you can’t tell it’s them anymore. Look, that’s why Iron Maiden dropped in sales when they replaced Bruce Dickinson with Blaze Bayley.

Maelstrom: I don’t mean to offend you, but I think Bayley sucks. I’ve heard people say that it’s because his style wasn’t right for Iron Maiden, but I’ve heard him in his other band, and it’s still not good. They could have gotten *anybody*. They could have had Micahel Kiske, or the guy who’s now singing in Angra.

Nicke Grabowski: I agree with you totally. I don’t understand why they got the idea of using him. Well, it’s a hard decision. There isn’t anyone that can replace Bruce Dickinson in a band like Iron Maiden. For a death metal band that has released one album, it’s not that hard to replace the front man, but for Iron Maiden... It would be the same if Niko McBrain dropped off, too.

Maelstrom: I’ve only noticed in the past few years how good of a drummer that guy is.

Nicke Grabowski: He’s really good.

Maelstrom: And he never plays double kick! But he does all that cool stuff.

Nicke Grabowski: That’s really cool. I was at a drum clinic in Stockholm with Niko McBrain. It was really amazing. Have you seen the Rock in Rio? It’s really cool, check it out. I mean, I think it’s a lot of people when I play for 600-800, but when you see 250,000 at that show.... It’s basically the same amount of people that live on Iceland. Have you ever been there?

Maelstrom: No. I’d like to go someday. Isn’t your girlfriend Icelandic?

Nicke Grabowski: Yeah, exactly! I went there and it was really cool. What amazed me most was that half the people live in the capital city. When you get out from there, the next biggest city, where my girlfriend is from, is like 16,000 people. And that’s the cool thing about Iceland: they have this amazing nature, with volcanic countrysides. And when there aren’t that many people, it feels like you’ve landed on the moon.

You can also see all those “manhood” cars they have there. You guys (Americans) have a lot of big jeeps, but I think they won the competition.

Maelstrom: Talk about your drumming on the new record. Have you learned any new tricks since last time? And if you have, how so?

Nicke Grabowski: (sigh) That was a hard question. I’ve always just played. The progression I see is that I’m getting better at the bass drums all the time. I’m very involved in the process of arranging the music, and that’s probably where I’ve progressed the most: writing music in the right way, and not putting too much drums where you don’t need to do it. I think the better you get, the less you do.

Maelstrom: Talk more about that.

Nicke Grabowski: When you’re not that good, you really try the whole time to do as much as possible, to prove yourself. But where I am now, I try to think more about the music. If there’s a song with almost no fills, and that feels right, then I would do it like that. It’s all about the overall feeling of each song, instead of being an instrumentalist.

We’ve already started writing material for the fourth album. It’s getting more about weaving the music so that it sounds like one unit playing. I do thin that the music we’ve done on the three albums is good and well-arranged, but if we make an album and feel we can’t do better, then all of us would quit directly.

Overdoing things is not good. It’s better to evolve the things you think you’re good at, and build your own style, and to learn other styles of music to put into your own. But being more laid back, and doing less, makes the music more powerful, somehow.

Maelstrom: ... like Bolt Thrower.

Nicke Grabowski: Yeah! Now we’re back at Bolt Thrower again! (Laugh). But then again, one of my absolute favorite bands is Death, and I can’t say that they have been laid back. When you hear the last one they did, you wonder, “is the drummer where he’s supposed to be?” When I first heard it, it sounded like a one hour drum solo.

It depends on what you want to do with your music. The drummers that Death has had, Sean Reinert and Gene Hoglan, and also Richard Christy, they’re all amazing. And they have all totally different styles.

Maelstrom: I need to listen to Human again. I haven’t heard that one in a long time.

Nicke Grabowski: That’s a gooooooood album. One of the best. I remember when I bought it, I was so amazed by the fast bass drums. It was released in 91' or something, and at the time, no one had done something fast and tight like that.

Maelstrom: That was the turning point for that band.

Nicke Grabowski: I think so too. Although you could hear the style on Spiritual Healing as well, and where they were going, the problem on that record was the drummer.

Maelstrom: Yes! He’s merely adequate in comparison. I guess you think he’s less than that.

Nicke Grabowski: Yes, actually.

Maelstrom: But going back to what we were saying before about perfection – and not defending the drummer on Spiritual Healing, but rather taking the angle of questioning these album that are artificially made to sound perfect based on the increasing demands of the genre – it’s nice to remember that it’s actual people playing it.

Nicke Grabowski: If we go back to Bolt Thrower once again, (laugh) and take them as an example, it’s about playing good songs. If your songs are really good, you can be sloppy. But if you’re too bad at your instrument, then it won’t matter.

Maelstrom: I see. Sure, if you’re really bad, it’s unlistenable. But if you make a mistake here and there, it’s almost cool. Where’s the line? I don’t know.

Nicke Grabowski: When some reviewers review a certain standard of band, they apply different judgements than on a higher standard of band. There’s a hierarchy of standards and expectations based on bands’ fame and status. The albums get reviewed based on that status, which is correct, but at the same time, you should look at them based on the state of the overall scene. I’ve noticed what I’m talking about in several big magazines. So, all you kids out there! Quit practicing! Just do metal!

Ahhh... well, I can’t really complain for our sake. I’m always nervous when we release a new album. What will the press say? The most important thing, of course, is the fans and what they think. But even if you’re a musician and you say you don’t care, you still want the press to like what you do as well.

(To be continued next month....)

 

 

 

interview by: Nikita
foreword by: Roberto Martinelli

Nikita loved this band Eight Days Gone. We thought she would. It’s clean and powerful and soulful, a very fine mix of rock and pop and grunge. Sure she’d be the best one to comment, but she’s gone AWOL from Maelstrom HQ. The authorities have been notified, the bloodhounds have been released, but we still need an intro. Here’s what she had to say about Eight Days Gone’s album Silence to the Naysayers in her review last month: “Eight Days Gone is a passionate rock and roll offering that’s smart, darkly dramatic and pops irresistibly.”

The following interview is with Neill Steinke (vocals, guitar) and John Zadeh (drums):

Maelstrom: I am really struck by how evocative and powerful the emotional element to your music is. Can you tell us anything about the life experiences that have brought the band to this point in its development?

Neill Steinke: It’s really a combination of all of life’s experiences to date. The struggle in music, the balances between family and career, how long can I hold off making my car payment before they start calling. I’m also more of an observer – I’d much rather absorb than participate. Inspiration is everywhere and I find it mostly if I’m not looking.

John Zadeh: Silence to the Naysayers best explains the answer to your question. We have been struggling very hard, both personally and mentally… trying to maintain a financial income and keep our dream alive. We have had a few bouts with certain aspects of the music entertainment business, which made us feel, at times, insignificant. We chose to live through it and write according to our own agenda. Silence... is a liberating affirmation for us.

Maelstrom: You’ve included some great soundscapes on the CD. What prompted the band to use these?

Neill Steinke: We really tried to exploit space on this record. We’re definitely into the ambiance of music and how it affects people. We try and create an environment where the music swirls around in the speakers. Joe Smith (producer/engineer) was really instrumental in helping us create that and fuse it into each song. I think subconsciously we all made a record that was somewhat relaxing to the ears but still bites enough to give you a little anxiety. The intro to the record is actually some binaural recordings. The assistant engineer on the project, Brad Johnson, and the second assistant, Jeremy Pannell, and I spent a couple of days getting different sounds from outside and around the studio. We used a set of AKG headphones with the speakers facing out and plugged into a portable DAT as a microphone. When you record from the ear’s perspective you get some really cool 3-D type imaging.

John Zadeh: Neill and I have a home studio where we cut demos, and he started experimenting with the soundscapes from that point. When Joe heard the demo, he was inspired to expand on what Neill had already started.

Maelstrom: Did you grow up in a musical household?

Neill Steinke: Both my parents played a little acoustic guitar and my mom played a bit of piano, but nothing serious. Mostly, we listened to music. My dad had a pretty extensive record collection. I remember that he had them all numbered with masking tape in the corners and then we would have them on a list so that we could find them quick. Every couple of weeks he would go through his collection and pull out three or four albums that I could have. At first, I never got the good ones, but as I got more responsible he’d share the good ones with me. It was my earliest exposure to music. I still have a handful of records my dad gave me.

Maelstrom: What single episode sealed you musical fate?

Neill Steinke: I was about 14 and I played the acoustic guitar in church with this guy Mitch who was a singer/guitarist. He had actually taught me my first chords and asked me to perform with him in church. We played “House of the Rising Sun” with the words to “Amazing Grace” sung over the top. It was really cool – the congregation applauded – I was hooked.

Maelstrom: What other bands have most influenced your music?

Neill Steinke: Matthew Good Band – they are from Canada. They have a really special way of exploiting space and atmosphere in their music. I’m also a huge fan of the Counting Crows. They are such an extremely talented bunch of guys, and Adam Duritz is such a great songwriter. I like how he can take the simplest words and give them such a huge impact. The entire band are huge Beatles fans. We listen to a lot of the Beatles on the road in the bus.

Maelstrom: The vision of this isolated trailer/studio is a really compelling birthplace for your music? What was it really like out there? What kind of equipment are you recording on?

Neill Steinke: It was an “add on” to s single-wide trailer. We put a sliding glass door where the hole was that connected it to the trailer and then threw in some new carpet and blocked out all the windows. We mainly have red lights so we don’t see the grunge, but it’s like a club... it stinks. The walls are yellow from nicotine and the floors are grey from spilling ashtrays. It’s a great vibe! We record all of our ideas in there now. We use two A DATs, a Mackie 24 x 4, two Yamaha digital mixers, and a variety of outboard compressors and effects. We keep telling ourselves that we’ll never leave because its our muse – but as soon as we get the chance we’ll probably throw gas on it and roast marshmallows.

Maelstrom: What is that on the CD cover?

Neill Steinke: It’s a tree. A very close friend of ours, John Kasye, does all our graphic design and web site stuff. I gave him the album and told him to give us art that was inspired by the record. That’s what he gave us. It’s beautiful. I love it. Everybody wins.

 

 

 

 

 
6.3/10 Roberto
 

MAGIC KINGDOM - Metallic Tragedy - CD - Limb Music Productions - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

I wonder if, when people come together to form a band in that hopeful beginning when dreams of having worldwide fans run wild, if the general consensus is to be generic. But, like, the best damn generic (fill in the blank) band there ever was. And to be excited about it.

And although every genre has the talented dopplegangers, power metal seems to be the most susceptible. The example du jour: Magic Kingdom. From top to bottom, from band name to cover art to song structure, this band makes every effort possible to not stand out from the genre in the least.

But there’s generic, and then there’s good generic. Magic Kingdom is definitely the latter. With a sound that is Rhapsody and Stratovarius, with some riffs nearly entirely lifted from these and other major bands of the style, Magic Kingdom manages to pull off a European-styled melodic metal ride that is not bereft or fun twists and turns.

And true to form of the power metal clones, Magic Kingdom have great musicianship to play the standard Baroque-played-as-metal solos and held-out chord verse riffs. The singer’s not too bad, either, but he isn’t convincing anyone he actually means any of the lyrics he sings about flying pyramids.

Within their own work, Magic Kingdom probably should have cut out the last track, the entirely too long "Metallic Tragedy." It suffers from two major flaws (aside from being too long).

- the saccharine, bass drum-laden music from the previous nine tracks is incongruous with the now forced "tragic" airs of this 13+ minute song.

- yet another misguided attempt by a power metal band to try to inject some fierceness (or legitimacy?) into their sound by including rough vocals, which invariably have the very opposite effect as they’re produced in exactly the same way as the rest of the record’s candy-coated sounds. C’mon, now. If your sound is all about being wimpy, then embrace it.

But we don’t want to be all down on Magic Kingdom. It can be good fun, but the audience is limited to rabid enthusiasts of the genre ONLY. For them, there cannot be enough of charging, classically-inspired melodic metal done ad nauseaum. And if you know what you like, what’s wrong with that? (6.3/10)

 

 

 

 
8.9/10 Jez
 

XASTHUR - Telepathic With the Deceased - CD - Moribund Records - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Having only recently been introduced to the works of Xasthur, I shall not attempt to compare Telepathic With the Deceased to their previous recordings. After a few listens, I would have to say that it is, by and large, and exceptional piece of work. Inhuman, harsh, and wonderfully atmospheric black metal, yet another jewel in the crown of the underground.

The cold, raw guitar sound gives voice to torment in tracks such as "Abysmal Depths Are Flooded" and "Cursed Revelations," as do the horrific death throes of Malefic. "May Your Void Become as Deep as My Hate" is both tortured and majestic, like a cry from the pits of despair. From a purely personal standpoint, I would suggest that any Nargaroth fans who are thus far unacquainted with Xasthur try this album for size. The darkness within the music is unique, and I would imagine that there have been many different reactions to it – pain, sorrow, adrenaline, euphoria, hatred, or possibly the soundtrack to your greatest fears. I myself will now be delving into their past releases, simply on the strength of this one. (8.9/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
Nocturnal Poisoning (issue No 11)  

 

 

 
9/10 Jez
 

FALKENBACH - Ok Nefna Tysvar Ty - CD - Napalm Records - 2003

review by: Jez Andrews

There are few bands in this world who can boast the same grandeur as Falkenbach. More that just music, their work is strengthened by feeling set within the folk-influenced black metal sound. The production may have been somewhat cleaned up around the edges since 1998's Magni Blandinn Ok Megintin, but the spirit has endured. Just epic in its own way, Ok Nefna Tysvar Ty is nothing short of magnificent. The passages of black metal vocals are fewer than before, but the songs are no less effective that the previous two albums.

Vratyus Vakyus has done a superb job of composition and arrangement, this time collaborating with members of Vindsval to produce a truly remarkable series of epic Viking metal songs. The additional clean vocals of Tyrann provide another layer to the sound which reminds me of early Ulver.

"...The Ardent Awaited Land.."' is an absolutely beautiful piece that takes a step back from the metal elements and simply weaves acoustic guitar tracks with vocal harmonies. Closing track "Farewell" is one of the finest Falkenbach songs I have ever heard, and indeed Ok Nefna... could well be considered their finest album, depending on what particular aspects interest you. (9/10)

 

 

 

 
5.5/10 Jez
 

VINTERSORG - The Focusing Blur - CD - Napalm Records - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Though it is still well constructed, I can find little appeal in Vintersorg's music. The Focusing Blur has sent them farther along the Opeth trail, with touches of Peccatum and Anathema on the way. Style abounds, but the substance is severely lacking. The sections of blasting with lacklustre black metal vocals are like their final grasp on the fringes of extreme metal. What with passages of lounge jazz and soulful, clean guitar breaks, I get the feeling that their next offering will be about as heavyweight as Anathema's Judgement.

That's not to say that this album isn't brimming with artistic flair. The diversity and complexity on offer is remarkable, and the lyrical topics can be somewhat baffling at times. Unfortunately, there is nothing really memorable to hold on to through the length of the album, and if any crowd is ever found to be singing along to "A Microscopical Macrocosm" or "Dark Matter Mystery - Blackbody Spectrum," then I could only assume that Vintersorg had been booked to play at a Stephen Hawking Lecture.

"Curtains" is musically the strangest of all the tracks, with its honky tonk piano interludes. I don't think the eccentricities of this material could be compared to the work of any other band, but there are more elements required than exceptional musicianship and complex ideas. As it is, it’s not very inspiring. (5.5/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
Cosmic Genesis (issue No 2)  

 

 

 
7.5/10 Jez
 

VEHEMENCE - Helping the World to See - CD - Metal Blade Records - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Vehemence are very much for the Gardenian, Arch Enemy and Disbelief crowds. This pensive and occasionally melodic death metal band have already raised many eyebrows and sent much hair flying, and from the sounds of it will continue to do so in the future.

I wouldn't describe Helping the World to See as a stunning album, but it has many charms. The riffing is superb and focused, complimented perfectly by the rhythm section. Perhaps Nathan Gearhart's vocals should have been clearer in the mix, but in general it works very well.

Among the more impressive tracks on the album are "You Don't Have to Be Afraid Anymore" and "Spirit of the Soldier," but I wouldn't say there are any weak tracks to speak of. The musicianship is simply faultless and overall, I'd say it's a fucking solid death metal album. What more can really be said? (7.5/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
God Was Created (issue No 12)  

 

 

 
8.4/10 Jez
 

LEASH LAW - Dogface - CD - Black Lotus Records - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Carrying on a grand tradition of American heavy metal, Leash Law are true veterans of the scene between them. At some point, I’m sure they have been slapped with the "power metal" label, but time has come to take a closer look. One quick spin of Dogface and I heard the meshed influences of Iron Maiden, Megadeth, latter-day Judas Priest, Primal Fear, and Iced Earth. Which I think paints the picture pretty well.

If you're in the right mood, Leash Law can pack quite a punch. There is considerable talent on display, and the variation is such that practically every track will hold your interest. By the time I was four tracks through, all I could think was how there needs to be more bands like this.

The only major criticism I would make is that the vocal melodies could do with some work. There are occasions when the voice of Wade Black (Crimson Glory, Seven Witches) seems to stoop to randomly pitched squawking. Don't get me wrong, the guy can sing , it's just something they should bear in mind for next time.

The riffs and soloing throughout, courtesy of guitarists Rick Renstrom (Rob Rock) and Emo Mowery (Nocturnus) are phoenominal, lying perfectly atop the powerhouse drumming of Death/Iced Earth man Richard Christy.

"Hail to Blood" is a real headbanger that sets the pulse racing with a nice, classic sound. Other stand-out songs include"'Better When Betrayed" and "Martial Law." Anything else that could be commented upon is for you to find out for yourselves...(8.4/10)

 

 

 

 
7.1/10 Roberto
 

ANCIENT - Night Visit - CD - Metal Blade Records - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Everything I had ever read about Ancient pointed to the notion that the band blew, big time. Well, more specifically, their first demos and debut album were good, but then it was all downhill from there... and fast. It all turned out to be true when seeing this most comical of all the bands coming out of Norway that call themselves "black metal," take the stage at Wacken 2000. I don’t know what was worse, the music, or the posing, or the presence of a sloppy, strumpet-looking woman whose only apparent role was as window dressing.

Hold everything. The new Ancient album, Night Visit, is really, really good! No, seriously, it rocks. Stylistically, if Old Man’s Child’s In Defiance of Existence is about halfway between Dimmu Borgir’s Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia and a "new" Immortal record, then Night Visit is about half way between Old Man’s Child and Immortal, but the cartoon version. And that’s cool. Enjoy it for what it is.

What’s the key to the success? Who knows? But it may be in no small part to the departure of that particular woman, who took with her almost all the "goth" wankery. Now, there still is a hint of this, on the first track, but the female voice over is minimal and in the background.

But the story is the songs, which rip and don’t become redundant. The vocals are kinda goofy, but the drums are polished but sound cool, the riffs are good fun, and Night Visit is pretty damn enjoyable. Were Ancient always this good? (7.1/10)

 

 

 

 
5/10 Roberto
 

CANS - Beyond the Gates - CD - Noise Records - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

The name says it all. "Cans." Not the most impressive name for a metal band by a long shot. You could pick from images of aluminum receptacles at a grocery store, or tired servants to target practice lined up on a wooden fence. Sure, power metal fans will figure out it’s a solo album named after Joacim Cans, the singer for Hammerfall. And while such a surname is ok in everyday life, or even in the liner notes of the album of a band by a different name, as the name of a band that sings in English, it’s just weak any way you look at it. Even "Joacim" would be better.

It’s for the best, as the greatest thing Beyond the Gates has going for it is the star status of its singer. The album is as generic as a metal album can be, which is largely the case with the solo projects of singers from notable heavy metal bands (a big exception that springs to mind: Bruce Dickinson).

If you’re a singer, naming a side-project band after yourself generally signals that you want the music to be all about your singing. And that’s fair. But neglecting to write any palatable music to go along with it is perhaps less than fair for the consumer. And as far as we’re concerned, the Cans record has no music in the form of anything resembling a memorable riff. Instead, Cans the band resorts to the tried and true held out chord or generic, two-note fast strum to provide the musical underpinning.

See, it’s much, much easier to sing on top of music that is practically just sitting there. You’ll hear most power metal bands do this: the riffs that you remember will be the ones played with no vocals; and when the vocals come back, it’s the return to the held-out chords. Then solos, which are generally also over generic metal riffing... it’s easier to solo on top of vanilla, too.

Contrast this with bands like Jag Panzer or Helstar or Dream Theater, whose vocals aren’t always catchy or even have a terribly coherent melodic sense to them, but consider what the singers are trying to sing over.

So I guess it matters what you want. You want to hear vocals and don’t care about the music? Then Beyond the Gates may be ok for you. But also consider that even vocally, and especially lyrically, the Cans record doesn’t seem to be making any effort at all, being content with rehashing rhymes and generic lyrical phrases about storms and dragons and whatnot. Really, any way you look at it, Beyond the Gates comes across as a terribly thrown together, afterthought record, albeit one played by stellar musicians and with a very good singer. (5/10)

 

 

 

 
8.5/10 Nikita
 

REVELATION THEORY - 6 Song EP - CD - Idol Roc Entertainment - 2003

review by: Nikita

This band might be "hatched" by the management company but they seriously rock! There is definitely something to be said for the connections and expertise in a management company that has the resources available to craft a market-driven vision.

They "discovered" a local NYC (or is it Long Island?) singer who has "the voice" and the stage presence, and proceeded to put the band together. (Never mentioned by name, I wonder if Idol Roc is keeping the singer and line-up’s identity their little secret?) I would be willing to bet there was some pretty demanding nurturing going on there.

Congratulations for sticking it out! A year and a half later the band has been deemed ready for the public. The concept seems romantically awkward for a rock and roll band’s beginning – but when music like this comes out the other end you just gotta relinquish. Revelation Theory’s hard driving performance on this six-song EP is nothing short of remarkable. Each song is a hit, ready to sing from a mountaintop or a stadium stage. The recording, mix and arrangements are brilliant! The voice and the instrumental parts are very dynamic and fused into simple, powerful songs with great titles.

So, Revelation Theory, who are YOU? I know who your lawyers are but I want to see YOU. Aptly and interestingly named, the CD comes to me demo style, without packaging or a photograph for me to sink my teeth into. I’m sure Idol Roc has a plan – and I do wager to bet it will be good.

I would travel to see this band play and I can be a freak about traffic. Better yet, I’ll fly out to take pictures – that way the parking won’t be an issue. Contact Maelstrom for Nikita. (8.5/10)

 

 

 

 
5/10 Rod
 

NOVA LEX - Resurgenic EP - CD - Testing Point Records - 2004

review by: Rod Togam

Amercian Duo Nova Lex produce an unusual blend of Metal (at times extreme), with electronic dance music. Such an odd merge may sound unfounded, baseless, preposterous even. Well, it kinda is.

Problem is, Nova Lex does not achieve a genuine synthesis between the two genres. The framework is conspicuously of the synthesized techno or trance sort. The progression of phrases is extremely linear and enclosed. The muted riffing guitars, as well as the growling vocals, seem to play the role of an alternative beat or sampler. Any kid who has ever played a bit with any computer-based recording software like Cubase, won't be able to help hearing the mental echoing of the digitized metronome playing in the background.

Everything in <Resurgenic> is square, neat and settled. While in the right measure, this could have been considered a positive trait of clever construction - in this case, when incorporated with an exaggeratedly thin and crisp sound - any original artistic idea is filtered by the wiping electro-feel. There is not much left to do other than joyously caper and cavort to the festive beat. Not that I did. Honest.

So, the interesting collision of approaches is never reached. The metal parts are mostly deathy/thrash sounding riffs, at times interesting and somehow innovative, at others not. The growling vocals are standard. The melodic ones often sound too similar to those of commercialized, post-death metal bands of late.

Now, the tragic thing about Nova Lex is that they actually seem to take themselves seriously. And they obviously do have the potential, be it in the shape of willingness to innovate, or an occasional creative approach to composition, and finely crafted instrumental skills. However, their obscure stylistic pretension inevitably wraps the jester's hat upon their head jester's hat.

But still, although the deserved criticism, one has to keep in mind that the music of Nova Lex, even if problematic, is still undefiably unique. And bizzare. And has some hilarious hooks and gimmicks to it. And therefore, surely as entertaining as any metal release may be. And as any disco release may be. And I hear the band sells the CD for only $5 or so. So maybe you should check it out after all. (5/10)

 

 

 

 
8.5/10 Tom
 

PECCATUM - Lost in Reverie - CD - The End Records - 2004

review by: Tom Orgad

editor’s note: When communing with the forces of the universe, Tom can be overwhelmingly analytical. So in the best interests of the erudite and dilettante alike, we developed a system we call The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly.

The Good:

- Peccatum has created a magical album, one that feels unified and coherent.

- the feeling of wholeness comes from how all the compositions originate from the same source

The Bad:

- not much to mention.

The Ugly:

- no more Emperor records, but probably more Peccatum records (says Roberto)

The Review:

Although at times rather distinctive and directional in its musical nature, the essential epitome of Peccatum's latest release is in its accumulative, atmospheric effect. By laying an intertwining of alternating, adjoining concrete musical ideas, the band manages to generate a magical synthesis, producing an artifact of complete unity and absolute coherence, embedded with enormous potential for a pure artistic experience.

The music on Lost in Reverie is composed of varying piano and orchestrated melodic lines and atmospheric sound layers. These draw a ponderous background to the distant yet emotive female vocals, expressing lyrics of poetic self-absorption, aware of its inherent despair yet ensconcing a sense of fragile, understated catharsis. At times, the calm, moody parts are replaced by fragments of thudding, distinctively distorted guitar phrases and raging drumming – which, while adding notable elements of aggression, still clearly maintain an overall feeling of surreal, enchanted, cleansed sterility.

However, the merit of Lost in Reverie is not to be found in its tangible, analyzable musical contents: the album delivers an atmosphere of an unmediated wholeness. Apparently, all of its different (and supposedly unrelated) compositions stem from the same essential source, inevitably reflecting the same muted longing of a screened, isolated stream of emotions, hopelessly craving for its lost, and currently unobtainable, source of authentic being. While not bearing any especially interesting elements to pinpoint (besides, perhaps, the high quality, innovative, at times even experimental production work), it allows the listener to undergo the rare experience of the absorption of a single driving state of mind, a total unity. While not being of an unusual atmospheric musical style (as of the ambient family), here, the experience of wholeness is derived from specific, stated musical sentences that almost parallels alchemy. Thus, one is to fascinatingly, knowingly experience multiple levels of musical existence, simultaneously: the more usual one of separate pieces, and the underlying, encompassing one.

Lest we forget to mention, the different layers are organized in a certain hierarchy: the concrete ones are subsidiary to the overall, atmospheric aspect. Hence, allowed an overwhelming simultaneous experience of clear directionality and significant engulfing ambience, one which is only to be found on most intriguing, rare pieces of music. This surely is an album to be withheld. (8.5/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
Amor Fati (issue No 5)  

 

 

 
1+1=2/10 Rod
 

THERION - Lemuria/Sirius B - CD - Nuclear Blast Records - 2004

review by: Rod Togam

Therion's promotional version of their two new albums (released simultaneously), doesn't feature both of the complete pieces. Instead, it includes a partial demonstration of the contents of each: six tracks from Lemuria, seven from Sirius B. Thus, Therion (or Nuclear Blast, or both – Roberto) disregard and contempt the essence of their artistic expression. Assuming that a reviewer may settle with merely half of the work in order to realize its full significance, testifies of a shallow, dull approach regarding the core of artistic creation (or a notion of album piracy – Roberto again).

Unsurprisingly, this state of mind is easily noticeable in the band's musical creation as well. Therion boast the fact of involving over 170 musicians in the recording of these two albums. This is their main source of pride. And indeed, the production is nothing short of superb. Involving a whole array classical parts in the form of lush orchestrations and dramatic, varied brands of operatic vocals, all professionally arranged and delivered, Therion provide a nearly unprecedented support to their metal-esque musical style. Surely, there is not much revival in this aspect of the band's creation: it seems that throughout their career,

especially since the mythic Theli album, the band have been justifying their existence and inclusion within the pantheon of leading artists of the world scene not as a result of their astonishing compositional or instrumental skills – which have always been rather banal and naive – but mostly due to the supplemental value of overwhelming production.

However, the band's unfortunate destiny has brought them to an era in which such efforts, although still impressive sounding, may no longer serve as a sole legitimation to the band's activity. Partially stemming from the precedents they have themselves set in the past, awsesome sound and arrangement appear today rather trivial, not sufficing to prevent criticism regarding the musical content itself.

Here, the nudity of Therion is publicly, embarrassingly revealed. Their music is composed merely of a collection of familiar metal clichés, overly dramatic constructed expressions, and a few harmonious noodlings on an oriental-sounding Phrygian mode. Nothing including the smallest bit of creative thinking. Nothing that is dissimilar to thousands of previously heard riffs, licks and movements. Nothing to wake the listener from his finely orchestrated slumber, not to say excite or evoke. Nothing. At all.

So, while pretentiously putting their confidence in a good classical arranger and a pitifully high recording budget administered to them by the record company, Therion allow their artistic flatness to reveal itself. It sounds great. With violins and all. (1+1=2/10)

 

 

 

 
5/10 Rod
 

RECORD OF SHADOWS INFINITE - Record of Shadows Infinite - CD - Crucial Blast Industries - 2004

review by: Rod Togam

Record of Shadows Infinite is a concept compilation, featuring selected works of drone and its various aspects – from amorphous, ethereal abstractions (such as Troum), through cacophonic, mayhem (Francisco Lopez), to a single appearance of languid, ultra atmospheric doom metal (Unearthly Trance). Other notable names include Amon, Chaos as Shelter, House of Low Culture and more.

One of the most essential characteristics of drone is its absence of a clear, coherent, directional musical concept. Such music is to be judged by standards of sound texture, density, the establishment of an associative musical space – what we sometimes call ambiance or atmosphere. It is not a matter of a linear musical development – more of a fine additive to a narcotic experience.

In drone the listener has to be gradually absorbed in the recurring inaudible waves of the slender sonic vibe, to become growingly submerged in subtle frequencies. For such atmosphere to be achieved, a continuous effect is usually required. Unfortunately, being confronted with 10 different tracks, lasting together for just a little over an hour, one is probably bound to face difficulties in becoming properly submerged in the surroundings created by each. The displayed abstract miniatures are too brief to be fully engaging; a possible profound experience becomes too fleeting and ethereal.

Some of the more straight-forward parts do manage to stand out. For example, the opening enchanting layers produced by Ruhr Hunter, or the avant-garde, multi-channeled tangle generated by Scot Jenerik. Still, the overall feeling of the CD is that of a concept-less concept, which may function as a basic sampler or teaser – not much more than that. A full album by any of the featured artists would probably be more worthy of a joint. (5/10)

 

 

 

 
6/10 Tom
 

SCENT OF FLESH - Valor in Hatred - CD - Firebox Records - 2004

review by: Tom Orgad

editor’s note: When communing with the forces of the universe, Tom can be overwhelmingly analytical. So in the best interests of the erudite and dilettante alike, we developed a system we call The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly.

The Good:

- Scent of Flesh has made a respectable album for the genre that it’s in (US-style death metal).

- a sense of subtlety and nuance in the framework of the tried (tired) and true.

The Bad:

- no attempts at doing anything that hasn’t been done before countless times over the past 15 years.

The Ugly:

- the guitar tone

the review:

Scent of Flesh play old-School, slightly blackened, American-style death metal. As being affiliated to such a common, veteran, restrictive movement, the creation of the Finnish quintet totters on the edge of legitimacy. However, it seems that they do manage to reap at least a certain amount of it, even if only by a hairbreadth.

Taking upon themselves the task of delivering a musical output of a most hackneyed and corny genre, they are placed under a constant threat of helplessly delving into the gaping abyss of vacuous, tasteless banality. Devoutly maintaining the ideas of their originating tradition, they’ll have to strive in order to achieve a shard of unconventionality to justify their existence in the artistic discourse.

Indeed, the product of Scent of Flesh bears much of the symptoms of the sorrowfully omnipresent phenomenon of vacuous recycling: each of their pieces proudly features a seemingly endless sequence of familiarly changing rhythms, circular patterns of raging blast beats supporting voracious growls, only to be unsurprisingly cut by an insulated, muted guitar, which inevitably leads to the next cycle of greatly earnest, at times infantly ambitious vehemence. The riffs maintain faithfulness to the strict, genuine standards of past greats in the genre. No innovation in terms of harmony, melody or rhythm is in sight.

However, the band does manage to create a certain atmosphere that perhaps deviates from the bromide nature of uncountable, despicably similar efforts which has surfaced in the underground and "overground" metal scene in the past decade and half. This is probably due to the conceptual clash occurring between the insidious ambitions notable in the bands work, and their somehow modern, uniquely formed manner of actual implementation. Indeed, the intentions of producing a work of subversive nature is emphasized on various aspects of the band's creation: the aforementioned lack of creativity is adjoined by an organic, loosened performance of the supposedly tight riffs, imparting the recording with a feeling of a live performance. Also, the guitar sound is exceedingly thin and flat, allegedly implying a lo-fi work of limited, dull material.

Nevertheless, these are clearly not the actual terms under which the recording and production of Valor in Hatred occurred: many of the coordinated phrases, guitar part entries, panning effects and their resulting atmospheres, seem to be surprisingly accurate, preconceived and subtle, adding a facet of distinctive, typical timbre to the album.

The atmosphere in certain parts has surely not been generated by a miraculous incident taking place in the gutters of a neglected, lacking recording basement. The echoing bass on the background of distant, flat drumming; the tight guitar harmonies and timing; the dramatic, planned entries – all testify upon an equipped, planning mind to be involved in the albums creation.

So, while the contents superficially sound crude and basic, the underlying framework is realized to be evolved and deeply contemplated. This combination, even if not unprecedented and exceptional, does bestow Valor in Hatred with a distinctive quality, which surely may render it appealing to fans of the genre. (6/10)

 

 

 

 
7.4/10 Jez
 

DRASTIQUE - Pleasurereligion - CD - Beyond - 125

review by: Jez Andrews

There’s something comfortingly solid about the Drastique sound. Like a cleaner, vampiric version of Opera IX, they may not be the most brutal, harsh or intense of black metal acts, but the combination of nicely reverbed drums and barking vocals is quite effective. Drastique's music fills the gaps left by Abyssos, with some pile driver riffing that can get the rib cage rattling almost as well as the double bass drum attack. Putting aside the keyboard tracks, I can almost make out brief bursts of Immortal influence and simplified Peccatum. The thundering bass of this album is one of its most prominent features, as is the gorgeous guitar sound.

The techno drum sample that dictates the intro of "Perfect Nothing" is slightly off-putting, but in general, Pleasureligion is quite a solid album. The vocals of Fay remind me a little of those of Cadavaria (Opera IX), and the clean vocals of composer Chris Buchman I would compare to either Star Industry or 13 Candles. The gothic overtones are the one element I found to be disappointing, but I would still recommend this to the many. (7.4/10)

 

 

 

 
8.5/10 Jez
 

DRACONIAN - Where Lovers Mourn - CD - Napalm Records - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Draconian continue along the path of doom. This latest offering of theirs is a most commendable piece of heavy gothic metal. Despite the shades of early Anathema and Tristania, I believe Draconian have utterly trounced them both with the brilliance of Where Lovers Mourn. One thing that sets Draconian apart from the scores of other such bands is that the doomy death metal voice of Anders Jacobsson actually has some depth and body to it, as opposed to those who believe the male vocals can be mediocre so long as the token gothic female soars high in the mix. This lot have it all: well structured, well orchestrated songs that provide a much-needed dose of soul therapy. Imagine Opeth with more life to them.

There is something strange about the sound on this album. On many occasions, I caught myself listening to each instrument individually before they merged in my head. In short, every track is wonderfully clear and powerful, allowing the listener to absorb every emotion the music has to offer. That said, it is only to be expected that after eight years of paying dues until the release of this, their debut album, they would have learnt a fair number of things about production.

Though the entire album creates a very sombre mood, the songs themselves are quite beautiful. To be honest, Draconian now stand head and shoulders above the likes of Crematory and My Dying Bride in the gothic metal field. And as for Lacuna Coil, don't even get me started. Listen to ANY track on Where Lovers Mourn and you'll understand. (8.5/10)

 

 

 

 
9/10 Jez
 

ILLOGICIST - Subjected - CD - Crash Music - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Illogicist seem to have ways of keeping the listener interested. The death metal metal element has been influenced by the old school, sure enough, but the rhythmic changes put me in mind of Dream Theater, Rush and Meshuggah. Subjected has a very full-bodied sound, and after some of the material I've heard this month, it does a fucking good job of keeping me awake. (Ed’s note: it’s been a good month for Jez, but see if you can spot the snoozer review)

The Italian trio of Luca Minieri (guitars/vocals), Emilio Dattolo (bass) and Diego Ambrosi (guitars) are joined by session drummer Remy Curtaz for some pretty special chemistry. Perhaps it goes well against the grain of traditonal death metal – even more so than Death ever did – but it's a fine piece of work. "Dissonant Perspectives," for example, is not something I would so much headbang to as wonder at.

The title track is heavily Death influenced again, with a few nice jazzy bassline ideas thrown in. The drum tracks provide a very solid backbone for the music, and that is NOT an easy skeleton to hold together. "The Soul Feeder" would have to be my favourite track, as it happens to display a perfect balance of muscle and colour.

To cut a long story short, whether you have a penchant for death metal or progressive, this is the album you NEED to get your lugs around. (9/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Avi
 

LEMMUS LEMMUS - Chameleon Mood Swing - CD - lemmus@muchomail.com - 2004

review by: Avi Shaked

The father, the son and the session musician. These are the three main factors that Lemmus Lemmus, a fresh-on-the-scene Israeli outfit (which performs in English), is made of.

Lemmus Lemmus, led by Joel Ron (the father, on guitars and effects), brings back lost sounds of late 60’s American and British psychedelia and melancholia, with influences from early Pink Floyd and the more bizarre "Tomorrow Never Knows"-Beatles, taken to a generally more reflective, depressing state.

"Retro-rock" is probably what you’re thinking – but, that’s a not a necessarily a bad tag. However, in this case it is also not a very suitable one, as Joel’s son, Eddie, brings a more up to date, grunge-influenced attitude into some of the work. It is no wonder then that there are sparks on this album that bring UK’s Gomez to mind – but while Gomez focuses on giving the 60’s R&B a new modern and often joyful treatment, Lemmus Lemmus is more concerned on inflicting relevance and sorrow into the 60’s psychedelia.

Noam Rapaport, a somewhat locally known session musician and a past member of various cover-bands, on organs and mellotrons, is a full and equal contributor to the creative process. He plays in the experienced musician spot, giving the album a more tamed approach that is colored with early progressive rock quotes.

But wait! The picture is yet to be completed, as there are additional guest musicians that came to spice things up with the presence of their instruments – in one point or the other you can find an aching cello, fit, 70’s styled drumming supplied by Rockfour’s Isaar Tennenbaum, and other surprises.

You are encouraged to take a peek at "Hands of Time" as a good representative track: it starts with a guitar melody that is not too far away from the Allman Brothers’ classic "Melissa," but evolves with hazy vocals, flute and semi-symphonic mellotron and Hammond-organ work to form a basic yet rich statement. A taste of early analog-electronic (with possible influences by Holger Czukay and Brian Eno) can also be traced here, and it continues to flourish on other tracks, in a restrained way that is typical of the entire instrumentation on the album.

It all comes alive with a tasteful, crystal clear modern production. However, at some places it sounds a bit fragmented or uncompleted, especially in the end of the long closing piece, "Silly Princess"; but that does not seem to take much away from the overall feel that this album implements on the listener.

Chameleon Mood Swing is mainly a contemplative effort, which offers a genuine feel and a unique voice. Sure, it is not perfect, but who says it needs to be perfect in order to be fully-realized? (8/10)

 

 

 

 
8.75/10 Avi
 

LARVAL - Obedience - CD - Cuneiform Records - 2003

review by: Avi Shaked

String instruments are threaded with cat-like howls repeatedly into an upbeat groove. Then, guitars introduce an overdriven, blues inspired melody, eccentric yet precise. Slowly, it all evolves into a great trained mess, before cutting into a contemplative quiet passage that is full of sadness and of menacing interpretations. Slowly again, it all turns into a parade of bizarre occurrences delivered via another loud rocking, melodic statement, only to roll you back to where it all began.

This is how the rock orchestra Larval introduces itself on the lengthy first track of Obedience, and it's pretty much the picture painted along the entire album in a very intimidating yet satisfying and surprising way.

Larval displays its blues and southern rock influences in a symphonic approach, building heavy atmospheres as well as climaxes in a way that brings King Crimson's "Lark's Tongues in Aspic" to mind. The orchestra’s detailed notes in a sea of desert-like melodies strike the listener like heat waves while comforting him like an oasis. Confused? So was I, as this music is full of conflicts – it's a part of their charm! ; And while patience and an appropriate mood are basic requirements from the listener, it's a charm worth exploring. (8.75/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Avi
 

FORGOTTEN SUNS - Snooze - CD - Magic Rope Music - 2004

review by: Avi Shaked

Forgotten Suns take influences from the hard progressive rock bands such as early 80’s Rush (there’s even a small homage to "Red Barchetta" on "Strange Affair with the Night") and Marillion. Therefore, it is not really much of a surprise to find out they sound quite a bit like early Dream Theater (which gathered their influences from similar territories), only not as technical and a bit mellower in tone.

So you might think that somewhere between Marillion and Dream Theater is really not such a good place to be in, especially since it is a place well-trodden; well, in most cases you’d be right, but Forgotten Suns, without a lot of originality (there’s really not a lot of place to blame them) but with a touching, honest performance, manage to make Snooze, their second album, work.

This lengthy conceptual piece (about 80 minutes that is spread, for whatever reason, over two discs) offers very melodic songs that revolve around the subject of snoozing through life (being passive and confused, missing opportunities, and so on). It is very gratifying once you get past the "weary, familiar terms" tag you’ll probably associate to it on the first listen.

With various hooks that keep you in focus throughout the album (and some of its lengthy epics), consistently pleasing guitar and keyboard melodies, dynamic instrumentations that do not go over the top, and a sincere vocal performance which sounds like a tender version of Dream Theater’s James LaBrie, this work manages to be more captivating than most of Dream Theater’s work.

While technical skills fanatics should stick with Dream Theater and co., the more occasional audience who can use a well written and performed, heartfelt, solid release should definitely check this out. (8/10)

 

 

 

 
6.2/10 Roberto
 

CANDLEMASS - Doomed for Live – Reunion 2002 - CD - Powerline - 2003

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Candlemass is weird. They make some of the best doom metal records in history from 1986-90, culminating in what has to be regarded as the band’s definitive line-up, fronted by the band’s most famous singer: the portly, monk’s robe-wearing, electric afro-coiffed Messiah Marcolin.

Then they release a fantastic live album and lose Marcolin. They make a pretty terrible album called Volume 6, or something. Band leader Leif Edling says he’s sick of the fantasy metal elements, and the band disintegrates and resurfaces with an almost entirely new lineup with Dactylis Glomerata (and the superb follow up, 1999's From the 13th Sun), with a doom sound that feels a lot like Black Sabbath’s self-titled debut. Excellent records, may we add.

So all’s well and good. But then they realize how much the classic lineup is loved by metal fans far and wide, and pull the Swedish version of the Black Sabbath reunion, playing festivals featuring material ONLY from their early, classic albums. Meanwhile, the band’s most current studio lineup is....?

Who knows? But like Sabbath, will it mark the end of Candlemass forever once the reunion period is over? Or will they make records like the hallowed ones from the 80s? Resurrected incarnation or new incarnation, we can only hope they’ll make something new. And while 2CD live albums of their reunion are cute, really, now, it’s not what the metal world absolutely needs by a long shot.

Doomed for Live – Reunion 2002's greatest asset, aside from the nostalgia, is the sheer volume of songs. And the sound is really good... and the intensity that comes across on Candlemass’ greatest live recordings seems to be in place. Classics like "Demon’s Gate" and "A Sorceror’s Pledge" are still as infectious as ever. But you can’t shake the feeling that something is a little tired on stage... or at least stale. Marcolin’s singing often trips over his zeal, and for some reason he never attempts the high notes that he occasionally did on his studio sessions. And while this is a good live record, and certainly one that any major Candlemass fan will feel compelled to pick up, it pales in comparison to the live album released in 1990, and maybe even to the live bits found on the 2CD remasters of the first four Candlemass classics. (6.2/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
Nightfall (reissue) (issue No 8)  
Ancient Dreams (reissue) (issue No 8)  
Tales of Creation (reissue) (issue No 8)  
Epicus, Doomicus, Metallicus (reissue) (issue No 8)  

 

 

 
4.9/10 Roberto
 

CREAM ABDUL BABAR - Excavation: 1995-1998 - CD - Public Guilt - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

We were all over the Cream Abdul Babar material from their split with Kylesa (reviewed some issues ago). It was rough, damaged and fierce; like an experimental, technical, sludgy metalcore. So we were pumped to get this 2CD album of this band’s earlier material.

Well... Cream Abdul Babar sure has come a long way since those earlier days.

Disk one is pretty tedious. The sound is good, but the music is some genre of simplistic, vaguely stoner rock played by irate surfers. The vocals are the worst of the bunch, being dimension-less screaming done without much evidence to attention to phrasing or delivery.

Disk two is remarkably better, but still nowhere near the material on the split. Here, the material is largely like the stuff on disk one, but the intensity and meanness is turned up considerably in sound, delivery and vocals. The best track here, and indeed of the entire album, is "Thomas P Rex," an electronic noise interlude that captures the essence of that split we keep telling you about.

You should know that I have a heavy bias against anything overly blues-based or that fits clearly in the "stoner" category. But I used to like it. And the stuff here isn’t bad, per se, just redundant and often unfocused. Don’t even consider buying this before you get the split. (4.9/10)

 

 

 

 
4/10 Roberto
 

RESCUE, THE - Phone Numbers - CD - United Edge Records - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Phone Numbers is continuing proof that mediocrity can become a bonafide genre, as long as its done long enough and by enough bands. In this case, the style is pop punk emo, with flat, range-less singing, some run-of-the-mill screaming, and music that’s on the hard side, but you still can’t shake the feeling that the guys making it are 120 pounds, soaking wet. Phone Numbers is an EP, and even then, it’s too long. (4/10)

 

 

 

 
3.5/10 Jez
 

ENSOPH - Opus Dementiae - CD - Cruz Del Sur Music - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

To the cybergoth brand of trendy black metal, and to all the real black metal fans out there, I sincerely apologise for soiling the genre by applying it to Ensoph. All I can think of when I hear this is the heinous treachery of ex-Dimmu Borgir bassist Nagash. To their credit, the vocals are a hell of a lot better than The Kovenant, and the drums, for the most part, have a genuine and full-bodied sound.

Though the effort has been made to make this album both diverse and bizarre, it's simply far too artificial. I suppose this is music for the tortured souls of goths to whom this crossover shit is the best thing since sliced bread. Despite the odd moment of bass-driven punch in "Sophia's Fall" and the occasional patch of nod-along riffing, Opus Dementiae is a depressing experience, plain and simple. The addition of piano and flute tracks into the mix does not lend Ensoph sophistication, merely weakness. At the end of the day, go for whatever flips your switch, but the only way the earth will move is listening to this during an earthquake. (3.5/10)

 

 

 

 
6.5/10 Jez
 

DEATH ANGEL - The Art of Dying - CD - Nuclear Blast Records - 2004

review by: Jez Andrews

Well, they're back. And style-wise, they haven't really changed, not that there's anything wrong with that. I'm all for bands staying true to what won them their fans in the first place. With the help of modern production, quality 80's thrash has come back with a vengeance. The most notable driving force this time around is the pounding basslines of Dennis Pepa, underlying the abrasive riffing of Rob Cavestany and Ted Aguilar.

Death Angel may not have been my favourite of the old thrash scene, but The Art of Dying makes for some damn good listening. Despite the occasional hint of drag factor, you can always hear that 80's spirit coming through in fine style, like that of Exodus, Destruction and Overkill. Considering that their comeback was originally meant only as a few reunion tour dates, I'd say Death Angel have done pretty well, especially with tracks like "Prophecy" and "Never Me." Even though I would compare closing track "Word to the Wise" to Pearl Jam and Alice in Chains before any thrash band, I would single it out as the most well written song on the album.

I wouldn't call this essential, but still a very commendable effort. (6.5/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Larissa P.
 

MOCK ORANGE - Mind Is Not Brain - CD - Silverthree Records - 2004

review by: Larissa Parson

I have the sneaking suspicion that this is one of those albums that will end up growing on me, so that three months from now, you will find me gushing about it, unable to wrest it from any and all of my stereo equipment. For now, I am intriguingly pleased with it. The lyrics speak to a certain angst that anyone who is working any desk-based job can relate to. Or a teenager, caught up the in mundane hideousness of being a teenager. Yet, while there are some decidedly strong sounds and some kickass guitars on this disc, it is hardly a screaming emo-fest.

The eighth track, "My God," asks the quintessential, existential questions of what anyone is doing anywhere in a manner that easily reminds one of Modest Mouse. "I Can’t Seem to Think," on the other hand, conjures images of sensitive guys strumming guitars beside a campfire, harmonizing closely while speaking of deep tragedies... roadtrips... driving away from the person you just broke up with.

All in all, this is a highly enjoyable CD that has enough variety of tones and sounds to keep you intrigued even on the tenth time through. And even if you want to skip the slow tracks to hear only the loud ones, the quiet ones will one day make it onto a mix-CD and haunt you. (8/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Larissa P.
 

HIGH WATER MARKS, THE - Songs About the Ocean - CD - Eenie Meenie Records - 2004

review by: Larissa Parson

Sometimes, you just want to hear a good pop album, but you don’t want to listen to something quite so flashy and highly produced as, say, Jem. If you pick up the High Water Marks’ album, Songs About the Ocean, you won’t be disappointed. This CD starts off high-energy, and just keeps riding that high all the way through.

With the always winning combo of two guitars, a female lead vocalist, and a sure-handed sound, it’s hard for the HWM to go wrong. While the influences on these multi-talented musicians (all of whom play in other bands, and frequently use different instruments in those other bands) could be easily discerned from a careful listen, none of them are overwhelmingly blatant, but rather make you feel a bit nostalgic as you listen. You are reminded of why you liked those other bands back in the day, and you are pleased that some people, at least, are still making music that sounds fresh. (8/10)

 

 

 

 
6.9/10 Bastiaan
 

VOID OF SILENCE - Human Antithesis - CD - Code 666 - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

Code666 has a habit of releasing bands that are always very interesting to look at, even to delve into a little, but only a handful of them actually prove worthy of the investment on the long run (I’m taking issue with that one – Roberto). Suffice to say that you should ALWAYS check out the bands this label puts out, but be wary of spending your money left and right before you are absolutely sure it’s what you want.

Void of Silence is one of those bands that float around on the border of worthy/not worthy. For some people who hear this, they will drop to their knees, clutch their hearts and thank who ever is out there for this next-in-line, miracle wonderland band that will forever remain the main interest of their hearts. For others… well, for others it’s not that dramatic. If you are among the dramatic metal heads, you can safely go out and get this right away, especially if you LIKE dramatic metal, because if anything, Void of Silence is just that.

I remain among the sceptical crowd, even after listening to this album for a week.

Granted, it is filled with:

- amazing parts that simply drip with black melancholy, forced out by lush and frail synths.

- long, drawn out songs that move seamlessly from one "holy" moment to the next.

- some excellent doom-ish guitar parts.

- long songs (the longest being the album opener at 20+ minutes) that stay interesting.

- DRAMA! (Alright, we get it, already! – Roberto)

Which is all good, of course, but the record is also plagued with at times shady vocals, a rather shady drum production (especially on the cymbals) and an all around shady feeling that listening to this album is slowly turning me into a drama queen (mission accomplished - endlessly butting in Roberto).

So unless you are absolutely CRAVING for some good old drama in the form of a metal band that is said to "set a new standard of quality and originality, creating a brand new music style," I call bullshit and tell you to give this pseudo-doom album a listen before buying it. (6.9/10)

 

 

 

 
0/10 Bastiaan
 

PLEASURE AND PAIN - Exit Gate - CD - Dream Cell 11/ Code 666 - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

Old school darkwave. Honestly, what more can be said about the releases in this genre that has not been said a million times before?

In the case of Pleasure and Pain: they offer it with a little twist, because otherwise no one would even bother with this debut album. It’s the same old story of heavily 80’s influenced goth electronic music, goth rock music, goth this, goth that, EXCEPT it is all thrown in together to create one super duper goth mix of… goth.

Really… you’ll have nothing to work with on this release, so just forget it even exists. (0/10)

 

 

 

 
7/10 Bastiaan
 

BROKEN HANDS FOR BRILLIANT MINDS - Remember the Past, Respect the Future - CD - Odd Halo Recordings - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

Ah, when I receive an album that comes in a lush package as this, I am immediately inclined to give it some bonus points; proving that the eye is not useless when it comes to music and especially not when it comes to receiving bonus points from yours truly.

Clint Listing, who is part of several interesting projects (which you should know and if not, go visit http://beautyandpain.com), takes on the woes and pains of ambience on his own and succeeds, to some extent… and fails in others.

We are promised a mix of Godspeed! You black Emperor, Mogwai, and others with elements of Lustmord and Raison d’Ltre, and looking at the song titles, a dash of Danny Elfman.

We throw those names out the window and instead focus entirely on the music itself because it only clouds the judgement. Let’s dive in, shall we?

We listen to the album, in the dark, alone and with eyes closed.

We come to the realisation that our throwing stuff out the window paid off because when focussed entirely on the music, we find ourselves tangled in a web of lush dreams. A dream that goes on and on without break and slowly lets us float out of said window (how ironic), into the pulsating midnight.

We come to a screeching halt after 42 minutes because Listing felt inclined to put 20 minutes of silence before the start of the last song (which we gather from the track list, is probably a bonus track). We blink and drop like bricks to the ground, rubbing our painful backsides.

A betrayal of sorts, after such a long and lovely journey into tranquillity. Not entirely sure if we should trust him enough to listen to the album again.

Listing succeeds in the main portion of the album AND succeeds in breaking the album in two in an ugly way. A dreadfully bad move that badly hurts the album’s chance of being essential. (7/10 with the break, 9/10 if you chop off the last 28 minutes)

 

 

 

 
7.5/10 Joshua
 

CATTLE DECAPITATION - Humanure - CD - Metal Blade Records - 2004

review by: Joshua

Everybody’s favorite (only?!?) veggie-agricultural commando squad hit back with their fourth excretion of environmentally conscious bedlam. The band continues to fine tune their approach with each release and Humanure finds them operating at full bore, creating havoc that’s akin to a bolt though the skull.

Sonically, this is an album of two minds. After the now beyond requisite intro, you’re assaulted by nine blasts of ultra heavy and hyper-technical death-grind. Pummeling rhythms propel each track, supported by squiggly guitar bits, guttural vocals, circular riffs and breakdowns so brief you’ll wonder if they were even there in the first place. The precision with which the band accomplishes this stew is fairly astonishing given that one misstep would bring the entire thing to ruin in the blink of an eye. A crisp production only enhances the meticulousness on display. No complaints here.

But. But… Closing track, "Men Before Swine," is the pearl in the offal heap. Sounding like a refugee from the Cold Meat Industry roster, it’s the aural equivalent of a slaughterhouse tour – nine plus minutes of creepy and disturbing atmosphere. Deep, rumbling bass drones evoke images of heavy machinery, turbines in constant flux. Agonized pig squeals move through that fog, propelled by none too comforting echoes of human voices mixed with the constant foreboding of rattling chains and metal striking metal. Entirely too effective.

Cattle Decapitation has nothing left to prove in the grind arena. It might behoove them to more fully pursue the avenue "Men Before Swine" has opened up as they are already quite capable in that setting. More, please. (7.5/10)

 

 

 

 
7.5/10 Roberto
 

DEMENTOR - God Defamer - CD - Osmose Productions - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

God Defamer is a celebration of terribleness, inside and out. But yet this complete void of taste or nuance is precisely what makes Dementor’s latest album not only interesting, but a pretty resounding success.

Dementor definitely has the sound of technology on their side. The guitars are as thick as concrete, but clear as a bell, and drums are absurdly huge. Match the impossible sound with the drummers utterly tactless style of playing – in which he never once lets up on the double kick, wild, Morbid Angel-inspired guitar solos that all sound the same (as do the songs, come to think of it) and you have a recipe for obnoxiousness... or so it would seem.

For the bad taste and murderous sound come together for an album that grabs you by the throat and simply impresses you with how fierce and focused it is, and indeed on that scale alone, God Defamer is one of the most impressive. Issues of how you might have done it aside, Dementor clearly have painstakingly formulated their sound, and based on their band name, have achieved it 100 percent. Sure, it’s the same thing over and over again, but God Defamer is pretty great fun. How much of that impression is contingent on their sound being cutting edge remains to be seen, but for a while, anyway, this is a recommendable album. (7.5/10)

 

 

 

 
9.5/10 Bastiaan
 

ATARAXIA - Saphir - CD - Cold Meat Industry - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

An album inspired by gardens.

Gardens? Yes, gardens.

We all know them, most of us have one. We all walk past them when we go outside, so why not make an entire album dedicated to gardens? What a brilliant idea.

And thanks to the variety of gardens, Saphir ended up having a variety of songs. You have gardens of the hanging variety, very rainy English gardens, peaceful and tranquil Chinese gardens and the exotic Arabic gardens. It’s much the same with Saphir. The booklet features wonderfully lush lyrics about said gardens; most of which are in English, but some in Italian and French, and unless you can read them, serve only as pretty looking filler (unless you are a geek and translate them).

Album opener "Azar" is a very exotic, acoustic guitar driven song that would fit perfect in an Arabic garden filled with thinly veiled, dark haired beauties. "The Gentle Sleep" on the other hand, stands out by the piano that one moment sounds frail and fragile, the next bombastic and menacing. Despite the excellent variety of songs and instruments (especially the percussion section is wonderful) there is one thing that holds them all together:

Francesca Nicoli. I think I am in love.

I have heard a dozen people claiming that her voice is what makes this album, another dozen that claims she breaks it, so make sure you give this album a listen before purchasing. I can understand the initial apprehension when hearing a first Ataraxia song; her voice is truly out of this world, almost floating above the gender attributes of man and woman, a unique voice in a league of its own, but if it is not to your liking, it will sound like a hoarse she-male that needs to be put out of its misery. But if it is, oh my... prepare to be enticed, romanticized and all around titillated because this is one sexy voice. (9.5/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
Mon Seul Désir (issue No 16)  

 

 

 
6.5/10 Joshua
 

KILLWHITNEYDEAD - Never Good Enough for You - CD - Tribunal Records - 2004

review by: Joshua

On first viewing of the CD’s booklet your brain might make the spatial leap that the band’s moniker is Killwhiteydead. If only. Now THAT would be a band name for the ages, especially coming from four presumably Caucasian miscreants. And just who is the Whitney in question? Please, not Whitney Houston. Her endless trips in and out of rehab, coupled with Bobby Brown’s jail stints are just too entertaining to put on the slab just yet, at least until Britney’s first Betty Ford Clinic visit is complete. Killbritneydead, anyone?

Never Good Enough for You comprises seventeen tracks of grinding Carcass-like business for its 30-minute duration. The album is elevated both by a guitar sound distinctively cleaner than that usually found in the grind field, and drums that could have been recorded in Pantera’s studio. Song titles, while amusing, ("You Like Knife Play? I Like Knife Play," "Who Said Alcohol & Handguns Didn’t Go Great Together") are perfunctory as there is nary a break between tracks. Killwhitneydead have a well honed grasp and command of the unexpected – black metal tinged vocals, an ample number of mosh parts, the utter hubris to insert power metal histrionics in the middle of the whole thing – that makes for a constantly shifting backdrop.

The glue that binds the whole deal? The raison d’etre? Samples. Dozens of them, everywhere. Beginning, middle, end. KWD, more than any band, (at least in sheer preponderance) utilize sampling as instrumentation. Half of the time they aren’t even integrated into the song structure, everything stops dead. On first listen this can be a bit jarring. However, once you realize that a sample from say, "Road to Perdition," is used instead of a guitar solo or chorus, it all makes a perverse sort of sense. KWD take sampling to its logical conclusion, making it a fundamental component of their song construction. This formula will undoubtedly get tired for more that another album or two down the road, but with Never Good Enough For You it works just fine, indeed. (6.5/10)

 

 

 

 
7.9/10 Roberto
 

GHOLGOTH - Somnus Mortis Imago - CD - Ordealis Records - 2003

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Of Ordealis Records’ latest crop of albums, Gholgoth looked the lamest, but turned out to be the best. With cover art that reminded us of the Dungeons and Dragons TV cartoon we loved so much as a child (anyone remember Venger? You might if you look at the back of the Gholgoth CD), we were expecting silliness.

But no. For Gholgoth means business, especially if you qualify business proportionally with the presence of blast beats. But what this Hungarian black metal outfit does so well is not so much play all the parts just great, but make the album full of nuances in spite of all the speedy rough housing.

Somnus Mortis Imago is filled with hooks, cool riffs and tasty morsels. The songs have nuances to them as obvious as a slow breakdown, or as subtle as a different harmony or drum fill. To make a long story short, if you’ve enjoyed the work of the black metal band Thy Infernal and want more, here’s the next album for you to buy. (7.9/10)

 

 

 

 
10/10 Bastiaan
 

BLUT AUS NORD - The Work Which Transforms God - CD - Candlelight Records - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

Apparently Blut Aus Nord has been around for 10 years already (and released three outstanding *and* utterly different albums – Roberto), reason enough to give themselves a big pat on the back, but to release what is one of the best black metal albums of the year is just frostbitten icing on their 10 year "we are Blut Aus Nord, watch us REDEFINE RULES" jubilee cake. Give them a big round of applause, please.

Also, apparently, there are two versions of this disc; I received the promo disc from Candlelight but when I mail ordered myself a copy (not from Candlelight mind you) I received a copy from some shady French label.

MAKE SURE you get the Candlelight version because seriously, whoever at the French label gave the "ok" to release The Work Which Transforms God has shit in their eyes. The artwork is absolutely horrible, you could do better yourself in Microsoft Paint.

Fucked up artwork antics aside; this record should be bought by anyone and everyone that even remotely enjoys black metal. Blut Aus Nord is one of those bands that damn well do as they please with the genre and actually turn it into something that just screams "IMPRESSIVE" and "EXTRAORDINARY," instead of just grim and necro. They are also highly under-appreciated, or even unrecognized by the majority; something that should change because they are deserving of much, and much more credit. Hopefully now with Candlelight, they can reach out to the US masses and get a little fame next to their name.

If you have any way of listening to this album before buying it, listen to the track "Our Blessed Frozen Cells" and you will be sold immediately! You will hear that it is not in the traditional black metal blast beat ridden songs that the band truly shines, but in the extremely sludgy funeral dirges that borderline hypnotize. If you want to take it a step further, put on "Procession of the Dead Clowns" and your life will be complete.

They could’ve put only those two songs on a disc and sold it, and I would STILL call it one of the biggest albums of the year. Downright amazing. (10/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
The Mystical Beast of Rebellion (issue No 9)  

 

 

 
8.5/10 Bastiaan
 

NORTT - Graven - CD - Total Holocaust Records - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

"Pure Depressive Black Funeral Doom Metal"

Six tracks, in total of a bit over 40 minutes, filled with that lovely catch phrase. I don’t know about you, but this is enough to either give me the jitters or make me roll my eyes and groan.

Nortt executes in style, so no eye rolling here. But there are several points of criticism that I need to vent. For one, the extreme, gritty guitar sound of black metal does not, I repeat, NOT, lend itself well to doom metal. Because the guitars generate such a hiss, it’s very hard to get into the guitar riffs themselves, which are, if you listen carefully, pretty damn doomy. Such a shame.

Second, because of said hiss, it’s also very hard to get a feel of what the album is all about apart from said lovely catch phrase. On songs like "Sorgesalmen" the sound would have benefited greatly if they had used a warmer, darker guitar sound. Now the intense beauty that is essentially what makes this track one of the highlights of the album is somewhat subdued under hiss and grit. Such a shame.

But if we look away from the doom parts of Graven, then we find a wealth of intensely bleak and melancholic music; almost depressing enough to get depressed but never depressing enough to actually begin tying a noose around your neck... just the way it’s supposed to be.

Graven is an essential album for anyone with a taste for the morbid; black metal fans should rejoice because the band takes the genre into something much more rewarding and lasting. Doom metal fans should "listen first, buy second" because of the guitar sound.

If you can get past the minor points, then you will enjoy what is one of the highlights of the year. (8.5/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Bastiaan
 

MELEK-THA - Perfect World Eradication - CD - Kubernoise - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

Ah, how blissful the noise genre is… how painful it is when no one understands what the fuck you are on about when you say, "damn, did you hear the latest Wolf Eyes release?" Everyone listening to noise goes through a situation like that every time he or she tries to converse about the musical side of life. Unless of course you are blessed with a city that thrives on noise, but come on, when’s that ever gonna happen?

So when I say, "damn, did you hear the latest Melek-Tha release?" you will all collectively say, "what the fuck? who?" and exactly ONE person, way over there in the back will say, "yeah man, excellent stuff." To whoever that person is, thank you for reading.

Melek-Tha is the demonic brain child of Lord Evil and his side kick Cyborg Drum Engine (probably IS a drum machine, but hooray for being sinister) and is actually less noisy than expected. Relying heavy on industrial beats, atmospheres and density, this record is actually a lot like something that would perfectly fit on the CMI bill, if it weren’t made by the French.

Personally, I would have liked to hear more noise in there, scraping metal on metal, hyper-sonic ear rupturing, screeching, contact mic laden NOISE, because it would give the album a much more violent edge. Here, the slow, brooding beats and atmosphere take the upper hand and lulls rather than pierce.

The first track starts off nicely: it’s very rhythmic in nature and somewhat noisy, but because of the subdued nature of the industrial edge, even the noisier parts come off as tranquil, and by the time you are eight minutes into the song you will be sitting back in your comfy chair, feet up and sporting a cig. The rest of the album works the same way, but sheer violent sonic moments are few and far between. Not quite what expected but very relaxing none the less. (8/10)

 

 

 

 
9.5/10 Bastiaan
 

DESIDERII MARGINIS - Strife - CD - Cold Meat Industry - 2004

review by: Bastiaan de Vries

If you look at the meaning of the word "strife," you will notice that it always comes with a tinge of violence. If you then listen to the album by Desiderii Marginis called Strife, you will notice that it’s a rather poorly chosen title unless the strife is in slow motion. If that’s the case, then it fits rather nicely. Whichever way you choose to look at it, the end result is the same; a beautifully, haunting album that is neither here nor there on the musical realm but rather floats above the borders in a gentle, somewhat sinister way.

Apparently Johan Levin is a big medieval nut. He dabbles in archaeology and works summers as an historical guide. Obviously this is the main reason why this record feels old; the man who created it pursues that which is old and often forgotten by the rest. Buried, out of sight, out of mind. But not for him. He carefully digs through layers of sand and rock to emerge covered in dirt with his hands clutched around musical gems that ultimately become the essence of this album.

"Blackout" is by far the most beautiful track on the album: starting out with scraping metal, rumbling drones, all subdued in delicious reverb, slowly creeping its way to the most memorable moment on the album. But you will only hear it if you dig, much like Levin himself, and get dirty below the ground. The reward will be beautiful, unless you pick the wrong artefact and end up with a curse on your soul.

An essential album for all ambient lovers, especially those who have a natural tendency to herald the ways of the old as the way to enlightenment. I really have nothing more to say other than good luck as I leave you at this dig site. (9.5/10)

 

 

 

 
6/10 Larissa P.
 

OTASCO - This Product Is Extremely Delicious! - CD - Apocalypse the Apocalypse - 2004

review by: Larissa Parson

Otasco are a group that works in two media: music and videos. To be quite honest, the music is much, much better when accompanied by the videos, which are wry, a bit rough around the edges, but decidedly interesting. Without the pictures, though, what you get is upbeat, sometimes spazzed-out (There’s a serious guitar solo. As in 80s style guitar solo) slightly geeky rock.

"The Last Bathroom Kneeling Party," for example, and its video, reminds you of all those parties you went to before, the ones you swore you’d never go to again. "Hoppy Drunk," sounds, well, hoppy. And so forth.

I think I’d like to see a movie written and filmed by Otasco, because they have a knack for storytelling and an interesting sense of sight. The CD, I suspect, will get a bit less play. I can listen to the Squirrel Nut Zippers for my quirky swing sound, Cake for my absurd story, and a long list of other groups for guitars. But I might have to watch the three videos (yes, an enhanced CD!) on the disc a few more times. (6/10)

 

 

 

 
6.5/10 Joshua
 

UNEARTH - The Oncoming Storm - CD - Metal Blade Records - 2004

review by: Joshua

When is a metalcore album not a metalcore album? When it’s a melodic Swedish death metal album. Alright, not entirely, but Unearth owes a hell of lot more to the avenues and byways of Stockholm than say, Peoria. Not that they don’t play metalcore in Sweden, it’s just... oh, nevermind, you get the idea.

Album opener "The Great Dividers" starts the proceedings in grand fashion and you’d be hard pressed not to believe that you haven’t stumbled upon the lost Slaughter of The Soul sessions – the heavy and the melodic meshing into one driving and unyielding force. It follows the Gothenburg blueprint to a tee. Where Unearth manage to avoid straight imitation is their insertion of metalcore tropes within the MSDM framework.

The Oncoming Storm is rife with short, punchy songs exhibiting catchy structures, stop-start rhythms and quick, to the point solos. Emo flavored vocal parts rear their head on two tracks ("Lie to Purify" and "Endless"), coming across more as a respite than focal point of each song. The emo card is played stronger, musically speaking, on "Aries," an achingly delicate, piano-driven piece that’s supported by vaporous guitar lines and anguished wailing set deeper in the mix. It’s the ideal soundtrack when dredging a haunting memory that refuses to fade; raw sound as catharsis.

Two tracks range from the constraints of both styles, adding more color to the band’s palette. "Bloodlust of the Human Condition" starts as a slow, downtempo number that imperceptibly gathers speed until it fairly blazes along before reverting back to its deliberate origin almost without detection. "False Idols" is an amorphous little demon, imbued with haphazard time changes that make it impossible to get a handle on the thing. These two songs, more than any other on the album, practically scream out Unearth’s mission statement: a deft appropriation of several different styles, reconfigured and set free on the world. It’s a familiar mutt that’ll surprise when you swear you know all of its tricks. (6.5/10)

 

 

 

 
8.2/10 Abhi
 

DISINTER - As We Burn - CD - Morbid Records - 2004

review by: Abhishek Chatterjee

Looking back, the cover seems aptly fitting for this album. Disinter's effort could be termed as primitive in the essence of its delivery. There is no dependence on triggered blasts or on ultra low vocals to make the output more brutal; instead what you hear is death metal played with conviction and energy. Their music could be described as death metal interspersed with moments of thrashing madness and melodic guitar work.

Skin ripping riffs hide behind numerous corners, like the one which pops out at the starting of "Murals of Horror" or the initial moments of album opener "Go Away and Rot!!!" The latter makes for a very unsatisfying opener though as it gets over much too fast and in a rather abrupt manner. The double bass pedal gets a good seeing to, but tends to become unnoticeable during the noisier sections.

Backed up by some solid songwriting, the songs have a nice flow to them though things do get a bit tedious with the last song, an acoustic reprise of the title track.

The strange thing about this album is that even though it is so enjoyable, the listener would be hard pressed to point out more than a few high points after listening to the whole thing. Disinter seem to be poised right on the edge; whether their next material crosses over to the level that As We Burn hints at remains to be seen. (8.2/10)

 

 

 

 
3/10 Abhi
 

MASTER - The Spirit of the West - CD - KMG - 2004

review by: Abhishek Chatterjee

Do you still listen to your Venom records? I don't. So after listening to The Spirit of the West a few times, I couldn't convince myself that I needed to listen to much more of this, either. Yeah, yeah, it's the legendary Master, and the truth be told, this isn't "bad" as far as rock'n'roll death/thrash goes. But it sounds so horribly outdated it makes me cringe visibly. Add to that some really cheesy and downright stupid wild west cowboy imagery, and even stupider lyrics ("I coulda, shoulda, woulda, but I didn't"!!) and you need to be a pretty loyal fan of this band or the genre to be able to digest this. Oh, the one thing on this album that gets a thumbs up from me: the well played solos. Other than that, it's goodbye for Master. (3/10)

 

 

 

 
7.4/10 Joshua
 

HATEPULSE - In Extenso Litalis - CD - Black Lotus Records - 2003

review by: Joshua

If you’re a devotee of Carpathian Forest, and you should be, this 0-minute offering of misanthropy is just the device to get a few drops of blood circulating towards your blackened little heart. Known associates Vrangsinn and Kulde conjure five missives of black metal weirdness, incorporating most of the elements that make Carpathian Forest so damn enjoyable, while expanding on those same components ever so slightly.

"The Cynical Aftermath" and "God of Hypocrisy" possess everything you’d expect: pummeling, buzz-ridden black metal, keyboards used sparsely and for contrast rather than accent. Standout track "The Avenger" is a throat grabber. After an intro with some horror movie piano noodling, it veritably bursts through the speakers like a tornado, twisting, chaotic and enveloping. A mid-song break  deposits you into the eye of the funnel, calm, yet eerie and foreboding, an all too short lull before you’re pulled back to the swirling bedlam.

"Suicidal Melancholia" utilizes a more deliberate tempo between  speed bursts, lending the song a more epic feel. Ghostly, choral sounding keyboards lurk in the background until they’re all that remain; a perfect evocation of the song’s title. Closer "Dodsferd" is a satisfying bit of oddness. If your CD player had a pitch control,  you’d be hard pressed not to think that parts of the song were  laying at 45 rpm rather than 33. In true Carpathian fashion, it works so well that you may forget that it shouldn’t work at all. (7.4/10)

 

 

 

 
7.7/10 Roberto
 

CRYFEMAL - With the Help of The Devi - CD - Trinity Records Hong Kong - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

If for nothing else, you have to admire the two guys in Spanish black metal band Cryfemal for risking life and limb in order to bring you this album. Their amps nearly killed them. These sound like they were wrapped up in Kleenex. The tissues are all inside the wiring, and the heat from them has caused the paper to ignite, resulting in a raging electrical fire that is consuming sound and matter. But Cryfemal play through it all.

And they did get hurt from this ordeal. Musically, imagine a badly wounded, disoriented Morbid Angel trying to play black metal. Add in a drum machine set to "drance-inducing speed," utterly weird keyboard ambiance, and completely buried vocals, and you’ve got the recipe for some pretty mind-bending and cult black metal obscurity. We think you should check it out. (7.7/10)

 

 

 

 
5.5/10 Joshua
 

RAVENCULT - Cosmic Chaos - CD - http://come.to/ravencult - 2003

review by: Joshua

Second demo of the Greek horde (their words). So keeping in mind the words "demo" and "Greek" in the same sentence, we’ll graciously cut them a little slack. After all, the Greeks did invent modern western civilization.

Cosmic Chaos isn’t bad by any means. However, the thin production found here is a detriment to a band whose members are certainly quite capable. A band who is aiming for the kult audience would thrive with this. But it’s obvious that Ravencult aspire to something more than that, given the often precarious, and sometimes ambitious, nature of the songwriting. First track "Pure Hellish Blasphemy" is an anomaly here, a perfect example of a band transitioning out of their origins. A two minute burst of blackened thrash, the likes of which you play when first putting together a band of this ilk.

The remaining three songs demonstrate that the band has already moved on from that standard, employing tempo changes, hints of melody and the odd refrain. "Manifestations of the Essence," a 7-minute stretch that sniffs at grandeur, makes use of a number of interludes, adding texture not found on the other tracks. It’s here that Ravencult distinguish themselves from the other members of the horde. Promising. (5.5/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Roberto
 

APHOTIC - Stillness Grows - CD - Flood the Earth Records - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Flood the Earth Records is off to a fine start. Their first release is of Aphotic, a very underrated doom/death band from the United States whose three recording sessions in as many years are compiled here on Stillness Grows.

One of the nicest aspects of this practical compilation is that the material largely sounds like it could have come from the same recording sessions. The style remains the same, the guitar maintains a defined and full sound, and it’s only during the last five tracks, from the self-titled demo, that you begin to get the hint that they were done at different times.

Sylistically, Aphotic succeed largely from their near constant application of guitar and keyboard harmonies within the framework of their simple music to weave a powerful, engrossing atmosphere.

If I had to pick an overall favorite, it’d be the middle four tracks, from the Under Veil of Dark sessions. The material here succeeds much like Katatonia’s Brave Murder Day in its layered, building simplicity. However, the organic, human drum playing on the first five tracks gives Aphotic its greatest appeal in terms of overall sound. Aphotic especially nail the production here, maximizing their intent with the sound by mixing the aforementioned guitar and snare drum in similar ways to great effect.

Stillness Grows would be something of a tragedy if Aphotic stopped here. It’s a highly recommended debut, of sorts, and let’s hope that the band can produce a full-length effort with the lineup from the first five tracks on this record. (8/10)

 

 

 

 
5.5/10 Joshua
 

CANVAS SOLARIS - Sublimation - CD - Tribunal Records - 2004

review by: Joshua

Remember the guys in school who were members of the chess club? Spent all their spare hours in the computer lab? Found solace and order in poring over some quadratic equations during free period? Well, they grew up and formed Canvas Solaris. Sublimation is the result of three enormously talented musicians who are more skilled now than you can ever hope to be. You will listen in admiration to their prog-metal compositions, awestruck by the intricate puzzles they construct. Perhaps you will even admit to liking them when no one’s around. And ultimately, as it was on the playground, you’ll steer clear because associating with such geeks is bad for your rep.

The musicianship is first rate but there’s a clinical detachment here that prevents any sort of involvement. It’s all a tad too perfect; there’s no risk. Other musicians of a technical bent will appreciate this, perhaps even find themselves immersed. Everyone else hanging out on the sidelines will grow increasing annoyed. Call it instrumental revenge.

The relatively short (three to eight minute range) songs do them no favors. This is the sort of music that thrives on long, drawn out compositions; sonic journeys that draw you in and eventually trap you by sheer force of will. Concision is the enemy. So is safety.

None of this matters though. Canvas Solaris don’t need our approval, but if you need a little more convincing in either direction, then play this little game: envision Pan-Thy Monium minus the weirdness and skewed world view and what is left?

Metal elevator music. (5.5/10)

 

 

 

 
6.7/10 Roberto
 

BY THE END OF TONIGHT - Fireworks on Ice - CD - Temporary Residence Records - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Ever since we received the promo of By the End of Tonight’s Fireworks on Ice EP, I’ve been consumed by getting myself a child’s drum kit. You may have seen these things. They look like regular drum kits, except about a third of the size. The bass drum is in proportion to the rest of the drums, but is about 14".

By the End of Tonight’s drummer plays one of these things on this record, and he’s got TWO bass drums. That is so rad. And the choice of drums makes a difference in sound, and greatly serves to give this instrumental group some signature.

The band has super chops. The four songs on display here feature that certain rawness that you can hear in Don Caballero, but with a much stronger metal element, like when the double kick shows up to go along with the more metal-tinged guitars.

But By the End of Tonight unfortunately suffers from all the trappings of a super talented instrumental band: it’s probably a lot more satisfying listening to the music if you’re actually in said band, or at most if you’re a technical music geek that gets off on analyzing music purely on a mathematical level. And while this band, who... and by the way, couldn’t we come up with a better name than By the End of Tonight? How about switching the name with Fireworks on Ice? Wouldn’t that be better?... Sorry.

As I was saying, while By the End of Tonight’s music has some visceral guts to it, it still hasn’t transcended being an impressive, likeable but not immensely compelling band. Still, it’s WAY better than the Canvas Solaris (in this issue), and no doubt more fun than Dysrhythmia. It’s just a hunch, but all these problems may dissolve if these bands bit the bullet and got some kind of vocalist. As it is, it’s good, but proceed with caution. (6.7/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Joshua
 

MAJHAS - Stepping into Character - CD - Hawthorne Street Records - 2003

review by: Joshua

Way before there was anything known as metalcore, there was a slew of bands operating on the fringes of the hardcore and metal scenes churning out noisy, disturbed albums of material too unsettling and fucked up for most of the inhabitants of those two camps. Unsane, arguably the most well known, heads list of bands that few knew at the time and many are only learning of now. Add Dazzling Killmen, Kiss It Goodbye and a good portion of the Amphetamine Reptile roster – Hammerhead, Janitor Joe, Cows – to name but a few.

Full of loathing and vitriol, with an arsenal of controlled discordance at their disposal, Majhas inhabit that same dark space. Where they have an advantage over their predecessors is three fold:

– They benefit from the gift of collective hindsight; a wider audience might now be ready to reap the rewards of this brand of unpleasantness.

– As veterans of various bands they arrive to this armed to the teeth rather then having to find their way to a musical endpoint.

– Their affection for experimentation finds elements of rock, doom, hardcore, and metal mixed into the noise-rock base, lending the songs an even greater unpredictability.

Three tracks stand out. The first half of "Nola Heat" scatters sparse guitar notes intermittingly against the dusty sounds of a 1920’s-era blues recording transmitting through speaker static. A lazy bassline plays tag with wispy high-hat smears, creating a syrupy atmosphere worthy of the song’s title. That atmosphere gradually turns to violence as the humid oppressiveness implodes, spewing heated shards of glass in every direction.

"Intermission" starts as just that: a minimal instrumental of over amped bass and random guitar/drum interplay. It slowly grows more cohesive, finds surer footing and steamrolls to a finish that ends in an unexpected coda of reverb and contained distortion.

The trump card is slammed down with "…Character," a 21-minute behemoth that propels the band into a different realm altogether. It’s a tour of the worst neighborhood your imagination can summon, concentric circles of hell that unveil horrifying visions around each corner and misplaced beauty thrown in among the detritus. If you can imagine the dark sprawl of Neurosis welded to the post-rock antics of Bitch Magnet or A Minor Forest mixed in with a smattering of guitar drone ala Troum then you’re off to a good start. Simultaneously expansive and claustrophobic, there’s nowhere to seek shelter in the open spaces where the walls are falling in. (8/10)

 

 

 

 
7.6/10 Roberto
 

CALIGULA - We Burn Bridges - CD - United Edge Records - 2004

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Caligula mixes excellent hardcore intensity with indie cool. About 70 percent of the We Burn Bridges EP is a fierce collection of intelligent arrangements, fierce metalcore blastbeats, and crushing guitars. But then when the music needs it most, the fare segues into relaxed, loungey material that is both tasty and palate-cleansing. Let’s hope Caligula doesn’t lose its intensity, but plays up their indie sensibilities even more on a full-length. (7.6/10)

 

 

 

 
8/10 Joshua
 

SUSPERIA - Unlimited - CD - Candlelight Records - 2004

review by: Joshua

Album number three and the evolution of Susperia continues. Fear not. This is a good thing. Rather than flailing around aimlessly searching for a formula that works, that band navigates the treacherous waters of change with aplomb. Whereas their debut, Predominance, was shining example of what one might term post-black metal, and Vindication dipped into a more blackened death realm, Unlimited finds the band opting for a blackened thrash approach. It’s a testament to the band’s talents that each album has succeeded in it own right and not merely by comparison to what preceded it.

If anything, the songwriting on Unlimited has actually been improved upon, no mean feat. What you’re given is simply a collection of songs; no epics, no forays into dissonance or experimentation. Most of the tracks clock in at the four-minute range, tightly constructed and compact. Every song is meticulously crafted with no free space woven into its fabric. This approach is ideal when you want nothing more than to throw your leather jacketed self against the nearest wall in unadulterated metal abandon.

There’s never been anything discernibly original about Susperia. It’s hardly mattered though as their vocabulary is vast and they’ve an abundance of ideas of what constitutes great songwriting. Harmony and melody are never thrown in at the expense of heaviness. Straight forward does not equate with uninteresting. With Unlimited, execution is once again paramount to originality.

Opening salvo "Chemistry" will transport you back to the halcyon days of 80’s German thrash, but with a sleekness which would have been inconceivable at the time. Vocalist Athera has ditched all but the merest hint of black metal rasp, now appropriating a Bay Area influenced bellow equal parts Chuck Billy and Robb Flynn. Whether it’s a melodic, fist pumping anthem ("Home Sweet Hell"), relentless bruiser ("Years of Infinity") or the soft/hard oscillations of "Mind Apart," he’s at the helm and in control. His vocal performance underscores each song with confidence and authority while freeing the music to dispense with the bludgeoning.

Outside of those who won’t venture beyond the grimmest underground recordings it’s difficult to imagine to whom this won’t appeal. Unlimited is a remarkable album in that Susperia haven’t calculatedly tried to be all things to all people. They’ve merely unleashed a wicked gem that will appeal to most of them. (8/10)

 

Related reviews:
 
Predominance (issue No 2)  

 

 

 
kult/10 Roberto
9.4/10 Mladen
 

STRIBORG - Nocturnal Emissions/Nyctophobia - CD - Finsternis Prioductions - 2003

review by: Roberto Martinelli

Striborg will do just fine as our monthly dose of occult-sounding, fucked up and fiendishly retarded black metal. This supposed one-man project from Tasmania, Australia is all about noise and the rain forest of Striborg’s homeland. Rain forest black metal!

The eight track album is split into two recording sessions. Nocturnal Emissions starts with the 20-minute song of the same name, whose first half is like the condensed hiss of a winter wind. Then it all starts to unravel in cult, stumbling black metal fashion.

You get fog, eucalyptus trees, ravens, noise, decrepit drum machine, and ambiance to rival the best the genre has ever put out. Sounds like a winner. (Kult/10)

review by: Mladen Škot (added 07/2007)

Instead of the usual precautions about Striborg, how about letting the music speak for itself? Just press "play." As a "screw you, I'm doing what I want" statement, hardly anything can beat an intro of three minutes of horrible trebly noise with one long, repeated scream over it. If you aren't "tr00" and "kvlt" enough, you're already looking for something else. Save your ears for Cradle of Filth or something appropriate for your age. Poser.

Nocturnal Emissions is a self-released 2002 Striborg demo. For those familiar with the Tasmanian, cabin-dwelling, one-man band’s work, there are no big surprises here. You expect majesty, you get majesty, period. All that is necessary to disclose are the nuances making Nocturnal Emissions different from the project’s other albums. Some of them concern the sound: Although always absolutely lo-fi, it seems that Sin Nanna never uses the same settings twice. This time the guitars are stripped of everything but distortion, but the bass can actually, sort of, be heard.

As slow as the riffs are, It's still hard to make them out. Played too loud, the guitar, combined with the continuous and persistent ride cymbal, sounds like a motor-driven wood file constantly scraping off the tissue the ear drums are made of. After a while, the listener might begin to fear that there's some kind of damage done, but the sound, translated into a physical force, forces him to stay and suffer. Speaking about black metal, this is what can be described as authority through arrogance.

Although 22 minutes long, the title track is mesmerizing. There's the trebly guitar filling the space, there are the thin, cruel screams, there are the apparently sloppy, but never repeating drum patterns, and there are the slow, gloomy keyboards for the first 14 minutes. But, once submerged in this, the minutes seem like seconds and seconds seem like hours. In other words, the space component is possessed, and the time component is irrelevant. Then the drums go faster, the riffs become clearer and the once-sloppy drums go for the "fastest drummer in the world" at around the nineteenth minute. But the atmosphere is intact. There's hardly a more efficient way to instantly get lost in a nightmare realm of your choice than this one.

The other three tracks of the Nocturnal Emissions part are not without surprises, either. "Despondant Cries" is as good a slow, persuasive track as anything Burzum has ever done, but where with Burzum you were being taken to the Scandinavian dark wastelands, Striborg proves that Tasmania has just as many threatening, unexplored places. Kid you not.

Also, there's no kidding with "Son of the Moon" or "The Freezing Northland" (that would be northern Tasmania, then) which are pure hypnotic violence, the latter done through a constant Darkthrone beat and silent, unequal, but dramatically disturbing bass. Who knows what the other instruments and vocals are doing, all the hope of seeing the light has been shattered and then scattered a long time ago.

Rain and thunder, along with the native Australian instruments announce "Under Black Rain" and the moistly sinister instrumental brings forth claustrophobic feelings of panic, being lost in a dark, vast, damp forest in the middle of nowhere.

The remaining three tracks of Nyctophobia (a 2003 demo) are classic Striborg, but this time played through a stinking, blood-soaked cloth. None more evil... though evil is an irrelevant topic here for it is a human invention. What Striborg is about, as confirmed by the superb lyrics (this time — usually they are random anti-human ramblings), is that the human race should be exterminated and erased from history, and Nature let free to blossom without obstruction. Most of the two-legged pieces of meat are just a waste of molecules and a failure in the evolutionary process. Not very hard to relate to. Let's just mention the whipping drum sounds in "Across Thornfields" and the macabre experience is complete.

So, is Striborg what you'd call music by the people, for the people? Yeah, right. Social types, better stay away. But, if you are looking at the world and yourself critically, detached, from a distance, and want to hear an aural equivalent of your thoughts, Striborg will take you as far as you want to go. (9.4/10)

 

 

 

 
5/10 Christraper
 

ARKHAM - Chapter III: The Madness from the Sea - CD - Battlesk'rs Productions - 2004

review by: Christraper

"Arkham plays exclusively in memory of H. P. Lovecraft and Cthulu's Myth"... that right there tells you what the shtick with these frenchmen is: an H.P. Lovecraft concept band. Lyrics taken from H.P. in English and in French translation. Scheeze! What, did they decide that Lord of the Rings was just "too played"? Très FROMAGE!

Of course, Cliff Burton himself wrote an instrumental song called “The Call of Cthulu” on Ride 'zee Lightning, but Cliff was fucking cool, that song slayed, and Metallica was completely fucking original, god-like and untouchable in their day. The “je ne sais quoi” of über sci-fi-horror, D&D-playing, video game-piddling, comic book nerdom was not what Metallica was about. THIS band, however, seems to lack a certain veritas.

I should back up here and say that Arkham - Chapter III: The Madness from the Sea is not completely heinous musically. It has its moments that are sort of interesting, somewhere in the spectrum of mostly mid-paced black to generic-metal that it undertakes. But it feels underdeveloped overall. Sorta like a group of well adjusted, talented suburban teenagers just getting their mainstream metal vibe on for the first time, with just a slight hint of necro to go. Listenable, not painful, but, but, but... (5/10)

 

 

 

 
2/10 Christraper
 

GOATFIRE - Fiendish Ruminations - CD - Total Holocaust Records - 2004

review by: Christraper

Oh, the misery! 78 minutes, 22 seconds comprised of five early demos from the band Goatfire. It sounds like rehearsal tapes, basically.

Here's what's written on the CD insert: "...this is the rawest material the band has ever recorded, poorly disgusting sound, distant noise and a massive dose of Black Metal the way we always intended it... most likely you won't be much pleased and that's fine." So right there, the band itself admits that this is for completists only. And if the band itself doesn't like their own release I, as your humble reviewer, am at a loss as to why I should be reviewing this. I think it sucks, too.

If you want to slog through over an hour of what sounds like your friend's brother's bass-less black metal band attempting to write songs in the basement, or you're just obsessed with all things Goatfire, then this is highly recommended. Otherwise, surely there are other goat be-named bands worthy of your attention. (2/10)

 

 

 

 
5.5/10 Christraper
 

MOONTOWER - Black Metal Terror - CD - Total Holocaust Records - 2004

review by: Christraper

Ohhh, spooky Casio keyboard intro! Then the guitars come in and it sounds all farty and "poorly" recorded. Yeahp, it's Eastern European BM alright. Raw, sorta thrashy, not too overbearing on the keyboards; another black metal record that's not really too distinguishable from other o.k. black metal records.

It fits the template: standard blastbeats, moody parts, wretched, reverbed vocals, suspiciously xenophobic songtitles like "Ancient Pride" and "The Honour of My Blood," etc... Speaking of which, "The Honour of My Blood" has one of those just stupid rock n' roll style riffs in the middle of it that saves this from being completely pedestrian and lethargic.

The song "War Passion" picks up some steam, too, but it's the second to last song, "The Tower of the Moon, Part II," that is probably the best and most worthy song on this record. It's sounds like a different band almost, all fuzzed out, "distortion pedal straight into the board" guitar sound, improved drums, epic feeling, another stupid rock n' roll turnaround in the middle... sweet, dude.

The last song is an early Bathory cover of the song "Armegeddon," more lo-fi than the original, and a bit unhinged, as it should be. Moontower – Black Metal Terror: two and a half songs out of 10 are worth it. (5.5/10)

 

 

 

 
 

 

 

 

YOUNG, NEIL - On the Beach - CD - Reprise Records - 1974

review by: Avi Shaked

Reviewing Larval’s Obedience during the last month or so threw me back to Neil Young’s On the Beach. I guess that it’s something that has to do with those symphonic desert-tracks; and since this is the second time I got an itch to write about this album for Maelstrom, I just could not let go again.

On the Beach might be a confusing title, and so is the album’s artwork. Sure, it implies the summer inspired mood, but there’s no leisure, get-a-tan type of stuff to be found here. Instead, you can find weary-tempered, semi-melodic songs – songs that puzzle and contradict in pretty much the same way the album’s front-cover does. It seems Neil Young could not decide if he should be on the optimistic side, or the pessimistic side ("Good times are comin', but they sure comin' slow").

The fast-paced opening track, "Walk On," does carry a scent of his old outfit, Crosby Stills, Nash & Young, but Young soon does walk on to an inner place and at a slower pace. While CSN&Y’s work was generally more hippie-lightweight-rebellious and harmony-dominated (check out "Almost Cut My Hair" and "Carry On" off their album DéjB Vu to get a good impression), Young brings a rawer and more intimate approach to this recording, leaning on basic song structures and a strong instrumentation that has nothing bombastic about it: the wailing slide-guitars, the vintage piano and the shy harmonica – they are all kept in minimalistic form, which only comes to serve Young’s personal reflections, which are wisely drenched in sharp criticism against the world’s evolution and its morally decaying population, and keep the listener interested enough to absorb it.

The songs are as contradicting as Young ("I need a crowd of people, but I can't face them day to day"). Besides the opening track, which really gets things going, the rest of the tracks are quite moody and thoughtful. At times, it seems Young, on the brink on depression, manages to find the light ("And there ain't nothin' like a friend, who can tell you you're just pissin' in the wind"); At other times, he points out wrongs, looking for a reason to drown in sorrow, or at least create awareness on the listener’s side ("You're only real with your make-up on").

And so, between Young’s shaky yet firm-handed performance, his playful licks and entertaining ideas, he lets the listener decide whether he should laugh or cry ("I'm a barrel of laughs, with my carbine on"); there is no wrong choice here – "It's hard to say the meaning of this song" – as Young suggests on this outstanding release, which was finally re-released for the first time on CD last year.

 

 

 

 
 

 

 

 

ORPHANED LAND
Theater Club, Tel-Aviv, Israel - June 22, 2004

review by: Avi Shaked

Hundreds of people – mostly adult teenagers that just started their summer vacation (although a bit of a wiser crowd was spotted, too) – squeezed in to Tel Aviv’s Theater Club to witness a rare Orphaned Land performance.

After a long wait, which might be credited to the strict security arrangements, the band roared on stage. A fine set, which included old classics ("The Storm Rages Inside," "Like Fire to Water," the always thrilling "The Beloved’s Cry," and a first live performance of "Flawless Belief"...) and a healthy amount of material from their latest release, Mabool, was forcefully executed. Emphasizing the songs’ brutal rhythms, and most certainly benefiting from the guest-presence of Yatziv Caspi on percussions, the band not only rocked the house – they rocked with their crowd; as it all seemed to turn into a wild, ethnic flavored celebration.

No, not even the terrible echo and poor acoustics could spoil the near-religious experience Orphaned Land offer to their headbanging followers. The audience was especially warm and cooperative, and though there was occasionally an awkward silence between songs, it was because the audience tried to give as much of itself as the band did during the songs that it needed a breath of air between them. It was no real surprise that most of the audience raised their hands when Kobi Farhi (vocals) asked who owned a copy of Mabool.

Keyboardist Eden Rabin did a notable job not only on his own sections, but also filling in for the absent oriental instruments, while guest female vocalist Shlomit Levi (on "The Beloved’s Cry," "A’Salk," "The Kiss Of Babylon" and others) shook ground and hearts with her wavy voice, and the rest of the band members were supplying their usual high-energy performance.

The long encore section completed the set tastefully, with songs that every fan longs to hear, like "A Call to Awake" (one of the most captivating tracks on Mabool), "Find Yourself, Discover God" and a sacred closer in the form of "El Meod Naala."

But still, Orphaned Land has yet to live up to its live potential. This would only be achieved once they integrate acoustic sections into their stage performance. Such a move should not be overly complicated, particularly with the current onstage lineup of two guitar players and two drummers; and in fact, it is inevitable – not only to please the fans with more delicate tastes, but also in order to bring their true, unique identity and personality that are captured on their studio recordings, into the live setting.

I can only hope to see them live again soon, preferably with better sound and with acoustic passages.

 

 

 

 

FALLEN SKIES
July 24, 2004 - Tap n Shine, Newcastle Upon Tyne, England

review by: Jez Andrews

There are certain difficulties to be endured by any band who perform at Newcastle's Tap n Spile bar. The downstairs room for live bands is reasonable good acoustics-wise, but as the setup of the "stage" area curves round a corner, the poor drummer is usually stuck back in an alcove, with little or no amplification. Newcastle-based power metallers Fallen Skies had pulled a decent crowd in from the rain, which was impressive given the trendy rock club alternatives available in this town on a Saturday night.

Kicking off their set with an enthusiastic rendition of Iron Maiden's "The Evil That Men Do," and went on to gain a loud response from the tracks of their first demo, "Sleepwalkers and "Illusion of Life." A fair number of well (sometimes strangely) chosen covers were blazed through, including Judas Priest's "Living After Midnight," Deep Purple's "Black Night" and Hammerfall's "Hearts on Fire." The band themselves managed to get one hell of a good live sound from their limited surroundings, and were much appreciated by those in attendance. I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of new songs "Mirror Never Lies" and "Sail to the Stars," both of which had a vaguely Stratovarius vibe.

Guitarists Sean and Marshall had a very well co-ordinated sound, not withstanding a couple of obscured solos. Finishing with an encore of "The Trooper" and "Creeping Death," I confess that it was not all what I expected from this outfit. To my knowledge, the only power metal band on the north-east live circuit, and they had managed to pull off a good show with a sizeable crowd, containing many recent converts to the scene. Things are looking up...