Untitled Document
Dear Maelstrom readers,
We’ve been looking forward to this issue for some time. Four
years ago this month, we launched this site. Since then, we’ve reached
a personal milestone of 30 issues. What’s more, with this fourth anniversary
issue, we’ve gone over the 2,000 review mark. Along with that, we’ve
posted 180 in-depth interviews, written up 82 concerts, including three Wacken
Open Airs, and featured 39 From the Vault albums.
All along, we’ve made friends, learned about the world and
how many of our favorite musicians make their music, and we’ve put it
up here to share it with any who would read. We’ve kept an eye out for
you by giving you our honest opinions about what was worth spending your money
on, and what was not.
The February, 2005 issue is no exception. Sixty-four album reviews
and two interviews – with black metal dynamos Mystic Forest
and Maelstrom HQ’s pick as the best metalcore band of 2004, Comity.
No live reviews this time, but we’ve got a warm, fuzzy write up of an
old Bolt Thrower album.
We've got a pretty rockin' contest for you this month. We're giving
away copies of the new God Dethroned digipak of Lair of
the White Worm, Psyopus' Ideas for Reference,
and Paria's Misanthropos. We've reviewd the first
and third album in this issue, and let us tell you that Psyopus may be the best
of them all. We'll tell you about it in detail next time, but suffice to say
that only Pig Destroyer can stand in its way of being the best grind album this
year. See our contest section for details.
Speaking of contests, thanks all who entered for last month’s
“Maelstrom’s Year End Grab Bag!” contest. Everyone who entered
will win something. More importantly, thanks all for your candid answers to
“what’s your favorite web zine and why?” We asked because
we wanted to know how we can improve. Some people said we were doing perfectly.
Others cited other sites as being their favorite. Some gave us pointers. I’d
like to respond to some of these critiques and comments.
From: devilmessiah@hotmail.com
Metal Observer. why? daily updates, cool weekly contests, alot of content.
A bunch of people cited other sites for this reason. It’s
certainly a valid one to surf into those zines. There is no way Maelstrom can
compete on these levels with sites like Metalobserver.com and Blabbermouth.com.
I, Roberto, in addition to running Maelstrom, have a regular job, a steady girlfriend,
am in two bands, practice drums everyday, work out three times a week and write
for and promote another webzine having nothing to do with metal. Oh, and a sometimes
I like to just dick around, like by playing “Grand Theft Auto.”
I’m impressed that any such site can become (seemingly) professional.
We can’t. The best we can do is monthly updates, or else I’d have
to give up my life. What we CAN do, maybe better than anyone, is...
From: kevin.dunkelheit@gmail.com
Maelstrom is basically the only webzine I go to. I think the others put in too
many bull shit reviews
This drove me nuts, too, and was the biggest reason Maelstrom
was started. We can bring you the kind of zine that I always want to read, the
kind that there are so few of: a zine where I can read an honest review of an
album, whose score isn’t padded and actually uses the entire numeric range.
From: dm2514@worldpath.net
I enjoy Maelstrom because of the mix of interviews and album reviews. The crew
manages to access a diversity I don’t encounter in other webzines.
Thank you. We write about music because we like it. We’re
not interested in conforming to self-imposed limits of what someone who likes
a type of music is supposed to like. We’ll review Cannibal Corpse next
to Cat Power, and love both of them. See our writers’ best of 2004 lists
for proof.
From: deadcradlemanson@yahoo.com
Not to be a kiss ass man, but you guys are the best. Whenever I read a new issue,
I know that the interveiws are deep and ask questions that I would ask, the
reveiws don't bullshit or surcome to popular opinion
Interviews that ask stock questions like “give us
a history of your band” or “tell us about the new album” or
“how would you classify your music?” show that the interviewer has
done absolutely no research or put in any effort to make the interview interesting
for anyone in the universe, including himself or herself. It’s shitty
journalism and a waste of everyone’s time. Thanks for noticing!
From: unitededge.---@xoxy.net
ones with working graphics?
Gasp! Do ours not work?
From: drwho89@hotmail.com
Maelstrom is my favorite web-zine for many reasons. The main one is that there
are good interviews that most other web-zines I go to don't have. I also like
the archives, although it is sometimes a little difficult to navigate through
quickly as there i...
Damn limited space... sorry you got cut off. Please tell
us more about this problem. We tried to configure the site so that it was as
easy as possible to check any of our thousands of articles. We wanted to make
the site issue-based for this reason, too. Could you please write in and finish
your thought?
From: metalhead0688@comcast.net
Maelstrom, because the awsome contests, great interviews, and having so many
reviews of great music that have turned me onto so many bands. Thanks for being
my favorite web zine. no improvement needed \m/
Wow. This makes the whole thing worthwhile. It’s good
to hear the stories behind all the faceless hits. We do it for you.
Thanks so much for all your support! Please enjoy the new issue.
Here are some of our writers’ favorite albums of 2004, and a some letters
to the editor.
– Roberto Martinelli
Alec A. Head’s
Top 10 of 2004 list:
ARCADE FIRE, THE - Funeral
MASTODON - Leviathan
ORPHANED LAND - Mabool
HAMMERS OF MISFORTUNE - The August Engine (not from 2004)
NEUROSIS - The Eye of Every Storm
TRAINDODGE - The Truth
CAVE, NICK AND THE BAD SEEDS - Abattoir Blues and the Lyre if Orpheus
ISIS - Panopticon
KILEY, RILO - More Adventurous
DREDG - Coquette demo
Bastiaan de Vries’
“Very Incomplete, but Still Filled with Wonder” list of 2004 (plus
explanations):
ACID MOTHERS TEMPLE - Close Encounters Of The Mutants
ACID MOTHERS TEMPLE - Minstrel in the Galaxy
ACID MOTHERS TEMPLE - The Penultimate Galactic Bordello Also the World You
Made
ACID MOTHERS TEMPLE - Does The Cosmic Shepherd Dream of Electric Tapirs?
- They released more this year, but these are the four main albums
that lead the pack. Everything they do, I love. My Japanese musical heroes.
AFRIRAMPO - Afrirampo
- Insane Japanese chick combo on guitar, drums and vocals. Heavy
rock with a an edge to be proud of. A funny edge at that. Combining care free
sexy attitudes with distorted guitars and pounding drums does wonders.
AIR - Talkie Walkie
- Another combo, French this time, doing what they do best. Amazing
10cc fueled electro-pop on an album that stays lush and comforting no matter
how many times you play it.
BADLY DRAWN BOY - One Plus One Is One
- Quirky, not as good as The Hour Of Bewilderbeast, but in its own
right a masterpiece.
FRANZ FERDINAND - Franz Ferdinand
- No nonsense Brit-rock-pop. A fun album for a fun evening.
RYLANDER, HENRIK - Traditional Arrangements of Feedback
- Insanely low rumbles topped off with even lower rumbles. Vast
and rhythmic, like organic living tar in your throat. Swallow away but it stays
there and suffocates. A perfect "with the lights out" record.
INTERPOL - Antics
- Only some filler on this otherwise remarkable album. Don't pay
attention to the underlying messages or meaningful phrases and this is a real
winner.
NEWSOM, JOANNA - The Milk-Eyed Mender
- A voice that you either love or hate. I love, and then some more.
HAINO, KENJI - Hikari Yami Uchitokeaishi Kono Hibiki
- This album is truly for only the strongest of heart. Rapist of
guitar strings Keiji Haino takes us on an acoustic journey. Atonal and discouraging
but ultimately rewarding for those who persevere and listen outside the box.
KINGS OF LEON - Aha Shake Heartbreak
- Another voice you either love or hate. I love, and then some more.
MERZBOW/CASCONE, KIM - Split
MERZBOW - Yoshinotsune
- King of noise, released much, much more this year. These two represent
everything that is great about Masami Akita and his PowerBooks.
MYSTIC FOREST - Romances
- The only metal release in my little list. Wonderful, extreme and
with a quirky melodic touch.
MÚM - Summer Make Good
- Icelandic girls and boys, insanely cute and talented. Truly delivered
one of the highlights of the year when it comes to quirky music. A magical wonder
of minute proportions. Small and fragile, an album to hold close and cuddle
with.
TELLIER, SEBASTIEN - Politics
- While this album only holds one song that is truly great, the
actual song is so great that it alone grants this album a top of the year spot.
“La Ritournelle” is one of the greatest pieces of music I have heard
all of last year.
STEVENS, SUFTJAN - Seven Swans
- Whatever has been said about this man has been wonderful and does
not need to be repeated. I will say this; he who makes good music with a banjo,
deserves all the praise he gets.
And now, just to be an asshole, the biggest disappointment of 2004:
ENSLAVED – Isa
- How these guys went from a masterpiece like Below the Lights to
a mundane and generic sounding “Isa” is beyond me. For shame.
Joshua’s Big Fat
List of Stuff he Liked in 2004 out of the Thousands of Things He Listened to
(in alphabetical order):
Joshua’s Top 28 of 2004
- Why 28? Because I said so.
- Played to death: Ministry’s latest. Get with the program.
- Once again, no apologies for some late discoveries, Aquacade being the prime
example.
- Those that didn’t make the rigorous cut but were oh so close: about
100 candidates.
- Essential cinema: “Hero.” If you saw it you know why. If you didn’t,
shame on you, your ancestors and your unborn spawn.
ALABAMA THUNDERPUSSY - Fulton Hill
ANENZEPHALIA - Noehaem
NORDVARGR BJORKK, HENRIK - Sleep Therapy Treatment (8 CD box set)
BURIED AT SEA - Migration
CARINO, PAULA - Aquacade
CLOUDDEAD - Ten
COLECLOUGH, JONATHAN - Makruna Minya
CULT OF LUNA - Salvation
DEAD TEXAN, THE - The Dead Texan
DEATHPROD - Box (4 CD)
ESOTERIC - Subconscious Dissolution Into The Continuum
FEAR FACTORY - Archetype
FOUR TET - Rounds
HECKER, TIM - Mirages
IRR. APP. (EXT.) - Ozeanische Gefuhle
MARTIN, CHARLOTTE - On Your Shore
MEADS OF ASPHODEL, THE - Exhuming The Grave of Yeshua
MESHUGGAH - I
MINISTRY - Houses of the Mole
MONSTER MAGNET - Monolithic Baby!
NARROWS, THE - The Skull at Life Size
NARROWS, THE - Alligator
RED HARVEST - Internal Punishment Programs
ROGERS, AMANDA - The Places You Dwell
SMITH, STEVEN R. - Antimony
TODAY IS THE DAY - Kiss The Pig
TROUM - Sigqan
WOVEN HAND - Consider the Birds
Larissa Parson’s Top
Something of 2004: The CD I have been obsessively listening to.
ARCADE FIRE - Funeral. And their live show at the great
American Music Hall.
Other stuff I really enjoyed, in no particular order:
MODEST MOUSE - Good news For People Who Love Bad News
WAITS, TOM - Real Gone
ROOTS, THE - The Tipping Point
BETA BAND - Heroes to Zeroes
FRANZ FERDINAND - Franz Ferdinand
WEST INDIAN GIRL
HARVEY, PJ - Uh Huh Her
WALKMEN, THE - Bows & Arrows
SONIC YOUTH - Sonic Nurse
LALI PUNA - Faking the Books
The CD from 2003 that I couldn’t live without last year: THE
SHINS - Chutes Too Narrow.
Matt Smith’s
Top Albums of 2004
MASTODON - Leviathan
HAUNTED, THE - revolver
CANNIBAL CORPSE - The Wretched Spawn
DECAPITATED - The Negation
MESHUGGAH - I
WAITS, TOM - Real Gone
SCEPTIC - Unbeliever's Script
Roberto Martinelli’s
“2004's Tried to Make it a Top 10 this Year, but We’ll See”
List
ANGRA - Temple of Shadows
CELESTY - Legacy of Hate
WINTERSUN - Wintersun
ARSIS - A Celebration of Guilt
DEAD TEXAN, THE - The Dead Texan
END - II
PIG DESTROYER - Terrifyer
COMITY - The Deus Ex-Machina as a Forgotten Genius (Andy Warhol Sucks)
TRANSMISSION 0 - 0
ENID - Gradwanderer
WEEPING BIRTH - A Painting of Raven and Rape
THUNDERBOLT - Inhuman Ritual Massmurder
BETHLEHEM - Mein Weg
ANATA - Under a Stone With No Inscription
ENDSTILLE - Frühlingserwachen
SIGRBLOT - Blodsband (Blood Religion Manifest)
it’s early yet, but I’m also going with PSYOPUS - Ideas of Reference
Favorite new album of 2004 that was in fact not:
ORATORY - Beyond Earth (I love you, Hanna)
Letters to the editor:
----Original Message Follows----
From: Nicholas Kong <nicholas.kong@gmail.com>
Reply-To: Nicholas Kong <nicholas.kong@gmail.com>
To: giorgio75@hotmail.com
Subject: Counterpoint to Tony Koretz's column
Date: Mon, 17 Jan 2005 17:36:29 -0500
Hi,
I read Tony Koretz's interesting article, and I would like to write
a counterpoint to it; if you think it's worth printing then
please feel free to.
-Nicholas Kong
Did metal cause the Columbus club shooting?
Certainly, a great tragedy happened on December 8, when Nathan Gale
shot and killed 5 people. Tony Koretz raised the issue of the relationship between
metal and the killing, and he postulated that the music genre played a large,
if not the main, role. In my opinion, there may be a slight connection between
metal and violence, but not one that is significant.
A similar argument has been drawn between video games and violence.
First person shooters like Unreal Tournament, and recently the Grand Theft Auto
series, have come under fire for promoting violent behaviour. But let me pose
this question: how many people, after playing a violent video game, feel the
need to kill someone? The extreme minority. So, how many people, after listening
to Slayer, feel the need to kill someone? Again, the extreme minority.
Of course, there will always be people like Nathan Gale, but you
cannot blame the music for what Gale did. It's an issue of
responsibility. People need to find some sort of quick fix, some scapegoat,
when the real issue is much deeper and much harder to address. It's so much
easier to blame movies or music or games than to study the real, societal issue,
or issues. What factors played in the development of this person? What were
the conditions like in which he grew up? These sort of questions will unveil
the real issue.
Now, it may be that metal and violence have a closer tie than, say,
classical music and violence, but then we cannot blame the music so much as
what sort of people the music attracts. Perhaps metal attracts a larger number
of psychopaths than classical music; but then metal had no part in shaping the
person. Nathan Gale was not a sane person. He was not a typical metalhead. Some
reports have stated he was obssesed with Pantera and as a result of the breakup
he bore a grudge against the former members. No matter what type of music you
listen to, behaviour like that is abnormal.
Think of John Lennon's killing by Mark Chapman and Selena's killing
by the former president of her fan club. Selena was a Hispanic singer and John
Lennon is pretty much as far as you can get from metal lyrically. Did anybody
blame the music for these killings? No. These people were insane, much like
Gale.
I'm not condoning hateful, violent or Satanic lyrics, by any means.
I personally do not find merit in them; I just feel that they are
perhaps being considered more powerful than they are. Whatever the case, a person's
actions are their own responsibilities. Any sort of entertainment cannot force
someone to do something, and so blaming entertainment is a form of evading responsibility.
In closing, there may be a relation between metal and violence,
but I don't think it's one to be significantly worried about by any means.
----Original Message Follows----
From: "Ronhead" <ronhead@wanadoo.nl>
To: "Maelstrom Zine" <giorgio75@hotmail.com>
Subject: Re: review link
Date: Wed, 12 Jan 2005 17:52:48 +0100
high ,
thanx man , honest one , bit pitty about the screaming vox - i think
its a matter of taste , but eh , what about the cd-extra part , complete with
video clip ? i`m gonna add it at our reviews-list , and for more update : we
are currently finishing our first - full-length - album , recorded in Rotterdam`s
Excess studio , known from bands as Pyaemia, Emeth , Disavowed ... , stage now
is the mastering , set for end of januari , we`re shooting a new videoclip again
,and we`re preparing a bonus disc , with a.o.live video footage , shot with
5 cams + soundboard sound ...
ok , grrreetings , Ron
http://www.vermin.tk